Louisville & Nashville Railroad v. Williams
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Lexington & Eastern Railway Co. v. Williams (Ky. Ct. App. 1923)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Opinion op the Court by
Affirming.
In February, 1919, this case, under a somewhat different style, was before this court on a prayer for specific performance of an option contract for a Tight of way, and an opinion was delivered which contains a complete statement- of the facts as well as the law 'applicable to this- case, in large part. See 183 Ky. 343.
(1) Appellees were allowed to recover damages for the obstruction of a private passway, which was not located entirely upon their own lands, but partly upon their lands and partly upon the lands of another, while “the obstruction complained of,” if there was an obstruction, was near the end of the passway and on the lands of a third person.
(2) The verdict is grossly excessive.
(3) The court gave to the jury erronebus instructions.
It will be seen, however, that the chief, if not the only error complained of by appellants is the failure of the trial court to admonish the jury at the conclusion of all the testimony, -not to consider evidence offered by appellees as to loss suffere'd by them by reason of the obstruction of the private passway.
This litigation started almost ten years ago. In 1910 the railroad companies obtained from one of the appellees, Hiram Williams, a written option of a right to appropriate a strip of land, 100 feet wide through his farm, for the purpose of building a railroad. Mrs. Williams did not sign this contract although she was the owner of an undivided one-half interest in the farm. The railroad companies started construction work to which Williams objected, and was threatening to eject the workmen, when the railroad companies instituted an action praying an injunction against Williams staying him' from interfering with their construction work. There was an injunction granted, but it was shortly thereafter dissolved on motion of Williams; in the meantime the railroad companies had instituted another action against Williams for specific performance of his option contract, and this latter action is the one in which the opinion, swpra, was rendered. While these two actions were pending, Mrs. Williams instituted another action in her separate name, claiming to be the exclusive owner of the tract of land and seeking damages against the railroad
The other two grounds urged for reversal are rested upon the one we have just disposed of, and the first one being without merit, the other two are rendered unavailing, for it is practically admitted by appellants that the damages are not excessive if the obstruction to the right of way could have properly been considered; and further that the instructions are n&t erroneous if the evidence concerning the obstruction of the passway was properly admitted. The right of appellees to recover not only for taking of the 1.4 acres of land as a right, of way but for all damages to the remainder of the farm, which directly flowed from such taking, was fully recognized and established by the opinion on the first appeal.
Judgment is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.