Tinsley v. Tinsley
Tinsley v. Tinsley
Opinion of the Court
Opinion op the Court by
Reversing.
Appellant, Marvin Tinsley, a colored man about twenty-three years of age, brought this action against America Tinsley and others for a sale of the real property belonging to the estate of Lewis Tinsley, deceased, and a division of the proceeds among the widow and heirs, including appellant, upon the averment that appellant is a son of Thomas Tinsley, the son of the intestate Lewis Tinsley. The answer denied that appellant Marvin Tinsley is the grandson of the intestate Lewis Tinsley or any way related to him, and charges that appellant Marvin Tinsley is an illegitimate child of Lucy Cray, now Lucy Patent. After the case was prepared by the taking of a number of depositions.on either side it was submitted to the chancellor and a judgment entered dismissing appellant’s petition and adjudging that he take nothing thereby, from which judgment he appeals.
It appears that old man Lewis Tinsley, a prosperous colored man living in Caldwell county, owned a farm of about eighty acres of land on which he lived, of the value of about $1,500.00, a one-half undivided interest in another tract of land containing about sixty-four acres and a house and lot of small value in the town of Princeton. He had three children by his first wife, two girls and a son named Thomas. There were no children by his second wife, America, who is appellee herein. About the time Thomas became of age he was courting a colored girl named Lucy Cray, who lived about six miles away from the Tinsley home. This girl was then about 16 or 17 years of age. Frequently Thomas in his buggy drove over to see Lucy and sometimes took her back home with him to stay two or three days with his sisters. This courtship went along for several months. Without warning Thomas suddenly skipped the country and a short time after his disap
This evidence is sufficient to establish Marvin’s right to participate in the estate of Lewis Tinsley, deceased, under section 1398, Ky. Statutes, which reads: “If a man having had a child by a woman shall afterwards marry her, such child or its descendants, if recognized by him before or after marriage, shall be deemed legitimate.” The law favors the legitimacy of children and will not bastardize a child unless the evidence is clear and convincing. Stein v. Stein, 32 Ky. L. R. 664; Bates v. Meade, 174 Ky. 545.
We have no doubt that Marvin is the son of Thomas Tinsley nor that Thomas Tinsley at the time of his marriage to Lucy and afterwards acknowledged Marvin as his child. This being so Marvin is entitled to inherit one-third of the estate of Lewis Tinsley, deceased.
We are unable to tell upon what ground the court dismissed plaintiff’s petition, whether upon the ground that Marvin was not the son of Thomas or upon the ground that America, the widow of Lewis Tinsley and holder of the homestead in the lands, was entitled during her life to the whole thereof, free from the claims of any and all of the heirs. From the evidence of America Tinsley we are convinced that she forfeited her right to homestead in the lands of Lewis Tinsley when she moved to Illinois to make her permanent home. However that may be, it is suggested in brief that America Tinsley is now dead and this question cannot again arise. She did not and could not claim a homestead in any part of the land other than the farm on which she and her husband lived at the time of his death. The . petition should not, therefore, have been dismissed and the trial court erred to the great prejudice of appellant in so doing.
As the chancellor did not pass upon a claim made by Mrs. Wall, a daughter of Lewis Tinsley, that the deed made by her to her father, Lewis Tinsley, was not in fact a deed but only a mortgage to secure her father against loss on account of money advanced by him to her, and did not determine whether the land was susceptible of advantageous division in kind or should be sold as a whole and
Judgment reversed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.