Bybee v. Singer
Bybee v. Singer
Opinion of the Court
On June 20, 1963, the appellant took an automobile to the appellee’s service station. Work was done on the automobile and as appellant was leaving he backed into a metal oil rack which was damaged along with some cans of oil. The appellee did not witness the accident. However, after the accident the appellant and appellee had a telephone conversation, during the course of which appellee demanded payment of $118.00 for the damages. Appellant proposed that the amount of damages be paid in installments. This proposal was rejected by appellee.
On July 11, 1963, appellee consulted an assistant county attorney for Jefferson County about obtaining a warrant against appellant and was advised that the facts presented constituted cause for a civil action but not one for which a warrant should be procured. On the same day a warrant was issued for appellant’s arrest based upon the complaint made on oath by appellee before a deputy court clerk charging appellant with willful destruction of property pursuant to KRS 432.240. On September 10, 1963, appellant was arrested on the warrant and was taken to the county police holdover in the courthouse, where he was detained behind bars. Later that day he was released on bail. The case eventually was dismissed.
Subsequently appellant filed this suit in the Jefferson Circuit Court alleging malicious prosecution. The trial court held, after hearing appellant’s evidence before a jury, that the appellant was guilty of violation of KRS 433.240 upon the facts submitted, and sustained appellee’s motion for a directed verdict.
The judgment is reversed, with directions to grant plaintiff a new trial.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.