Receivers of C. Doyle & Co. v. Kleinkemper
Receivers of C. Doyle & Co. v. Kleinkemper
Opinion of the Court
---This suit is for the recovery of ah
The answer admits that defendant subscribed for twenty-five shares but avers that subsequently his subscription was cancelled to the extent of ten shares, thereby reducing his subscription to. fifteen shares, which he has received and paid for.
The plaintiff offered no evidence whatever. The only proof in the case is the testimony of defendant who, while admitting his original subscription to twenty-five shares, testifies that he subsequently requested the vice-president of the corporation, who had solicited his subscription, to have same cancelled to the extent óf ten shares; that such cancellation was made and that he was so informed by the vice-president; that he paid for fifteen snares which were issued to him over the signature of the president and of the secretary of the corporation, and that he was never notified of any further liability nor called upon to pay for the additional ten shares until after the corporation became insolvent and passed into the hands of the receivers. He does not recite, nor in cross examination was he requested to state, nor does the record, otherwise disclose what formalities were pursued in effecting the cancellation, but the Court is of the opinion that upon the facts related he has made out a prima facie case of cancellation, for his uncontradicted statement that a cancellation was in fact effected carries with it, in the absence of any proof to the contrary, and of any evidence that the corporation was then insolvent,
The Court below properly rejected plaintiff’s demand, and its judgment is accordingly affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.