Carbons Consolidated, Inc. v. Hall

Louisiana Court of Appeal
Carbons Consolidated, Inc. v. Hall, 179 So. 878 (1937)
1937 La. App. LEXIS 496
Hamiter, Taliaferro, Drew

Carbons Consolidated, Inc. v. Hall

Dissenting Opinion

DREW, Judge

(dissenting).

I respectfully dissent from the majority opinion in this case for the reason that I am of the opinion that the omnibus clause in the insurance policy covers the case and makes the insurance company liable thereunder. In my opinion the driver of the car causing the damage was lawfully in possession of same at the time of the accident.

Opinion of the Court

HAMITER, Judge.

For the reasons assigned in Edward Parks v. Harvey Hall et al., 179 So. 868, this day decided by us, the judgment appealed from, in so far as the defendants M. L. Gans and Phoenix Indemnity Company are concerned, is set aside and reversed, and plaintiff’s suit is dismissed at its cost in both courts.

Addendum

On Rehearing.

TALIAFERRO, Judge.

For the.written reasons this day assigned in Edward Parks v. Harvey Hall et al., on rehearing, La.App., 179 So. 868, the judgment heretofore rendered herein is reinstated and made final.

DREW, J., dissents.

Reference

Full Case Name
CARBONS CONSOLIDATED, Inc., v. HALL Et Al.
Cited By
3 cases
Status
Published