Foremost Insurance Co. v. Blue Streak Enterprises, Inc.

Louisiana Court of Appeal December 13, 1977

Foremost Insurance Co. v. Blue Streak Enterprises, Inc., 353 So. 2d 430 (1977)

1977 La. App. LEXIS 3954

Du, Duplantier, Gulotta, Plantier, Stoulig

Opinion of the Court

DUPLANTIER, Judge.

We affirm the trial court’s decision that a boat owner (or his subrogee) who pays a monthly fee for use of a boat slip in a marina cannot recover for the loss by theft of his boat moored in the slip, in the absence of proof of negligence on the part of the marina operator.

As did the trial judge, we reject appellant’s contention that a depositary relationship existed between the marina operator and the boat owner; they were merely lessor and lessee.1 The boat owner paid a monthly fee for the privilege of mooring one or more boats in the space in the marina and for using electricity and water. He could remove his boat or boats as he wished and secure it or them as he wished. The boat was never delivered to the marina operator, an element essential for deposit. (Art. 2930, Civil Code).

The judgment of the district court dismissing plaintiff’s suit at its cost is therefore affirmed.

AFFIRMED.

. See Richardson v. Port Vincent Boat Works, Inc., 284 F.Supp. 353 (E.D.La.).

Reference

Full Case Name: FOREMOST INSURANCE COMPANY v. BLUE STREAK ENTERPRISES, INC. and Continental Insurance Company
Cited By: 2 cases
Status: Published