Sabine Pipe & Supply Co. v. McNamara
Sabine Pipe & Supply Co. v. McNamara
Opinion of the Court
Appellant filed a pleading it calls “Motion to Dismiss.” The brief in support calls it a “Motion to Dismiss Appeal of Appellee with Respect to Penalties .... ”
Appellant sought relief in the Board of Tax Appeals from the assessment of taxes, interest and penalties. The Board affirmed the assessment of taxes and interest but “vacated and set aside” the penalties. Appellant secured a review of judgment of Board of Tax Appeals. Appellee filed an “Answer to Petition for Review of Judgment of Board of Tax Appeals” in which she denied that the “Board of Tax Appeals committed any error either of fact or law, and asserts that the judgment of the Board was in accordance with law and therefore should not be modified or reversed.”
Appellant’s “Motion to Dismiss” asserts that appellee is precluded from raising the question because of this failure to appeal or answer the appeal. We are inclined to agree that the question is not before us but we find inappropriate a motion to dismiss an appeal that is not an appeal. We decline to add to the confusion.
MOTION TO DISMISS DENIED.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.