Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2011

Health Education and Welfare Federal Credit Union v. the Peoples State Bank

Health Education and Welfare Federal Credit Union v. the Peoples State Bank
Louisiana Court of Appeal · Decided December 7, 2011 · No. CA-0011-0672
Health Education and Welfare Federal Credit Union v. the Peoples State Bank

Opinion

STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL, THIRD CIRCUIT

11-672

HEALTH EDUCATION AND WELFARE FEDERAL CREDIT UNION VERSUS THE PEOPLES STATE BANK

**********

APPEAL FROM THE

TENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT

PARISH OF NATCHITOCHES, NO. 82,294, DIV. B HONORABLE DEE A. HAWTHORNE, DISTRICT JUDGE

**********

ULYSSES GENE THIBODEAUX

CHIEF JUDGE

**********

Court composed of Ulysses Gene Thibodeaux, Chief Judge, Jimmie C. Peters, and Billy Howard Ezell, Judges.

AFFIRMED. Bernard Slattery Johnson Kristina B. Gustavson Cook, Yancey, King & Galloway P. O. Box 22260 Shreveport, LA 71120-2260 Telephone: (318) 221-6277 COUNSEL FOR:

Plaintiff/Appellee - Health Education and Welfare Federal Credit Union Christopher Michael Sylvia P. O. Box 1200 Many, LA 71449 Telephone: (318) 256-4383 COUNSEL FOR:

Defendant/Appellant - The Peoples State Bank THIBODEAUX, Chief Judge.

In this redhibition matter, Plaintiff Health Education and Welfare Credit Union (“HEW”) filed suit against Defendant The Peoples State Bank (“the Bank”) seeking a return or reduction in the purchase price of a mobile banking unit sold to HEW because the automated teller machine (“ATM”) on the unit was defective at the time of the sale. After trial, the trial court ruled in favor of HEW, finding that the Bank breached the warranties of fitness and fitness for a particular purpose. The trial court awarded HEW $13,308.00 in specific damages. The trial court held an evidentiary hearing on the issue of attorney fees and costs. The trial court issued a final judgment and awarded HEW attorney fees and costs in the amounts of $53,042.00 and $4,191.19, respectively. We affirm.

I.

ISSUE

We must decide whether the trial court abused its discretion in awarding $53,042.00 in attorney fees to HEW.1

II.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The facts in this matter are not in dispute. The underlying action stemmed from the sale of a mobile banking unit from the Bank to HEW. The trial court awarded HEW $13,308.00 for the replacement of a defective ATM that was part of the mobile banking unit. The trial court held a separate evidentiary hearing to fix the amount of attorney fees and costs.

In advance of the evidentiary hearing, HEW filed its Motion and supporting proof seeking $58,962.00 in attorney fees and $7,141.44 in costs. At the hearing, counsel for the Bank only generally opposed the amount of attorney fees sought by HEW. The Bank’s counsel failed to specifically object to any of HEW’s itemized invoices and was admittedly unprepared to do so. The trial court granted the Bank’s request to file a supplemental brief to specifically challenge HEW’s invoices. HEW subsequently filed a brief in reply.

After the evidentiary hearing and after reviewing both parties’ briefs concerning the invoices, the trial court issued its final judgment and awarded $53,042.00 in attorney fees and $4,191.19 in costs to HEW. The Bank appeals the amount of attorney fees awarded.

III. LAW AND DISCUSSION Standard of Review

We review an award of attorney fees in a redhibition case for abuse of discretion. Buteau v. Leleux, 591 So.2d 1261 (La.App. 3 Cir. 1991). As this court stated in Buteau, “[b]efore this court will disturb an award by the trial court, the record must clearly reveal that the trier of fact abused its much discretion in making the award.” Id. at 1266 (citations omitted).

Discussion

The supreme court articulated ten factors to be considered in reviewing the reasonableness of an award of attorney fees: “(1) the ultimate result obtained; (2) the responsibility incurred; (3) the importance of the litigation; (4) amount of money involved; (5) extent and character of the work performed; (6) legal knowledge, attainment, and skill of the attorneys; (7) number of appearances made; (8) intricacies of the facts involved; (9) diligence and skill of counsel; and (10) the court’s own knowledge.” State, Dep’t of Transp. and Dev. v. Williamson, 597 So.2d 439, 442 (La. 1992). The supreme court noted that these factors were derived from Rule 1.5(a) of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Id.

A trial court is afforded much discretion in awarding attorney fees in a redhibition case. Dailey v. The Home Furnishings Store, 02-1225 (La.App. 4 Cir. 9/17/03), 857 So.2d 1051. Attorney fees should be awarded on a case-by-case basis after examining the factors listed above. It is not per se unreasonable, as a matter of law, for the attorney fees award to be greater than the award for damages. Id.

At the evidentiary hearing in this matter, the trial court was presented with a plentitude of documentary evidence. It is clear from reviewing the trial court’s ruling and reasons for judgment that the court meticulously analyzed that evidence before awarding attorney fees. We see no reason to re-hash its thorough analysis, and we find no abuse of discretion in the amount of attorney fees awarded. Thus, we affirm, and we adopt the trial court’s well-reasoned opinion as our own. Its opinion is incorporated by reference as Appendix “A” to this opinion.

IV. CONCLUSION

For the reasons articulated above, we affirm the judgment of the trial court, adopt its opinion as our own, and incorporate its opinion by reference. Costs of this appeal are assessed against The Peoples State Bank.

AFFIRMED. r CJ i q fV D

HEALTH EDUCATION AND DOCKET NUMBER 82

294 B s WELFARE FEDERAL CREDIT UNION N VERSUS 10TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COUR THE PEOPLE

S STATE BANK NATCHITOCHES PARISH LOUI ANA

RULING AND REASONS FOR RULING CONCERNING ATTORNEY FEES AND COSTS

The Court previously awarded the plaintiff Health Education and Welfare Federal Credit Union HEW the amount of for the 308 replacement of a defective ATM which was a part of a mobile banking unit MBU that was sold to HEW by the defendant The People s State Bank PSB The court also awarded reasonable attorney fees and costs to HEW to be determined at an evidentiary hearing to fix the amount to be awarded The reader is referred to the s written reasons for Court judgment concerning the case on the merits which is incorporated herein by reference

FACTS

HEW filed its Motion and

Application for Court to Fix Attorney s Fees with attached supporting proof i e invoices documents affidavits etc HEW is seeking 58

00 in attorneys fees and 7 962 44

1 41 in costs This amount of attorneys fees includes 5

000 estimated post judgment future fees The defendant PSB filed a Response to Plaintiff s Memorandum in Support of Motion and Application for Court to Fix s Fees Without any particular basis for

Attorney its argument PSB asserted that s fees should be fixed in the amount of attorney

5 00 one half of the amount awarded to replace the defective ATM machine built in the MBU it sold to HEW ynuf c v r iDtisthe

C t d I f i tf iC i 1DC At the hearing PSB was not prepared to argue in opposition to any specific charge on the invoices submitted and filed in the record by HEW s counsel While PSB did raise general questions about whether it was reasonable for HEW to have two attorneys for the trial and whether the redacted time entries should be considered it was s

PSB position that the amount awarded to HEW for replacement of the ATM should essentially be the only or main consideration in determining attorney s fees PSB argued that the attorney s fees should be set at no more than the amount awarded for replacement of the ATM

Ultimately PSB s counsel asked for permission to file a post hearing brief in which he would address the individual invoices entered in the record The Court granted his request and allowed a response to be filed by HEW Consequently HEW felt it necessary to respond

ANALYSIS

Attorney fees are only recoverable when authorized by statute or contract Fontenot v State Department of Public Safety and Corrections 625 So

2d 1 122 1124 La

App 1 1993 The trial court generally has much discretion in setting

Cir an award of attorney fees Short v Plantation

Management Corp 781 So

2d 46 65 La l 2000 While a court App s attorney fee award should not be modified on appeal absent a showing of an abuse of discretion it is not without parameters but is dependent on the reasonableness of a particular sum Id This reasonableness inquiry applies where attorney fees are established by statute as well as by contractual agreement

City of aton Rouge v Stauffer Chemical Company 500 2d 397 400 So 401 1987

La A trial court has great discretion in awarding attorney s fees in a redhibition case

Dailey v The Home Furnishings Store 2002

1225 La App 4 Cir 9

1 7 t

857 So

2d 1051 citing Philippe v Browning Arms Company 395 So

2d 310 La s fees should be awarded on a case

1980 Attorney by basis after examining many factors It is not unreasonable as a matter of law for the attorneys fees to be greatex than the damage award Id

The Louisiana Supreme Court in State

Department of Transportation and Development v Williamson 597 So

2d 439 441 42 La

1992 set out the factors to be considered by a court in reviewing the reasonableness of an award of attorney fees

1 the ultimate result obtained 2 the responsibility incurred 3 the importance of the litigation 4 amount of money involved 5 extent and character of the work performed 6 legal knowledge attainment and skill of the attorneys 7 number of appearances made 8 intricacies of the facts involved 9 diligence and skill of counsel and 10 the court s own knowledge

The Supreme Court noted that these factors were derived from Rule 1 a of the Rules of Professional Conduct

1 the time and labor required the novelty and difficulty of the questions involved and the skill requisite to perform the legal service properly 2 the likelihood if apparent to the client that the acceptance of the particular employment will preclude other employment by the lawyer 3 the fee customarily charged in the locality for similar legal services 4 the amount involved and the results obtained 5 the time limitations imposed by the client or by the circumstances the

6 nature and length of the professional relationship with the client 7 the experience reputation and ability of the lawyer or lawyers performing the services and 8 whether the fee is fixed or contingent HE W s counsel attached a memorandum to its application to fix attorney s fees and costs citing a number of cases therein which the Court has considered as well PSB filed memoranda as well citing other cases The Court has taken all of these factors into consideration in determining the reasonableness of HEW s s fees and costs attorney

Hourly Rate Charged s counsel Kristina B Gustavson graduated with honors from Tulane HEW

University and has approximately 7 years experience in the field of commercial law She has had experience practicing in two large law firms known for excellent work

The Court finds that the skill of the attorney handling the case for HEW is without question She did excellent work She was well prepared and responsive to the Court at all times She diligently provided the Court with numerous detailed and thorough memoranda r uested by the Court on all legal issues and on the complicated facts of this case There were numerous documents involved in this litigation and HEW s trial counsel had all of these documents well organized Presentation of the evidence showed that counsel was well prepared and skilled at eliciting the necessary facts and explanations of complicated technical information and with managing the many documents in court Trial bench books were prepared for the Court which made the trial run smoothly With lesser skills this trial could have taken twice the time that it did

Actually PSB did not question the skill of HEW s counsel PSB did not appear to raise any specific question concerning the hourly rate charged by HEW s counsel either but simply left that determination to the Court HEW trial counsel charged an hourly rate of 200

00 per hour While this may be on the high side in our small community for all of the above reasons the Court does not find it to be unreasonable s Specific Objections to Charges on HEW Attorney Invoices PSB

In its hearing memorandum PSB reviewed each invoice and raised post several specific objections in regard to some of the charges PSB had specific objection s invoices s to 14 of HEW 1 In regard to 13 of those invoices an objection is raised to fees associated with redacted time entries for a total of 3

6 20 in charges The Court has read each one of the redacted entries and does not find the redactions inappropriate Nor does the Court find the charges to be unreasonable which charges appear in large part to be for consultation with client personnel The attorney had an obligation to keep her client informed as well as to prepare s objections to fees personnel for trial Therefore the Court rejects all of PSB associated with redacted time entries 2 PSB objects to the fees charged by the attorney partner BSJ at the rate of

250 an hour PSB objects to 4 of these entries 100

00 4 hrs on Invoice No 34508 00 5 hrs on Invoice No 36026 75 125 00 3 hrs on Invoice No 39362 and 00 5 hrs on Invoice No 43453 for a total of 425 125 00 The time charged by BSJ was minimal The work done by BSJ does not appear to be duplicative nor does it appear that BSJ is generall Y overseein g work P erformed bY Ms Gustavson The charges are reasonable The Court will not disallow these charges 3 PSB objects to fees charged for what it deemed to be excessive time charged for research In this regard PSB objected to Invoice No 34508 asserting that HEW s counsel had charged b hours for trial attorney researching law for a total of which includes the word research was by SSS and was marked N

C indicating there was no charge There were several entries described as analysis one for analysis regarding causes of action against PSB and broker for 2 hours one for analysis of Louisiana law regarding venue and jurisdiction for 0

60 hours and one for analysis of principal place of business of entities and of Louisiana law regarding foreign corporation filing suit in Louisiana for 0

40 hours for a total of 3 hours

The Court notes that even if 6 hours were charged for research it does not find devoting 6 hours to research excessive There were a number of different issues that needed to be researched concerning code articles or statutes as well as cases relating to those issues In addition throughout the litigation issues arose which the Court equested that the attorneys research and brief for the specificall

Court The Court of its own knowledge is aware of the time necessary to properly research and address these issues

PSB raised this same objection to Invoice No 38403 s counsel

HEW charged 2

1 hours for research PSB objected to the entire charge and believed that the expenditure was unnecessary The court disagrees This issue and how it applied to this particular case was a serious question This charge was not inappropriate nor was the charge excessive

There were no more specific objections to time charged for research 4 As to Invoice No 34508 PSB raises only 3 other specific objections PSB objected to the charges for drafting and revising an analysis and for drafting and revising the petition On Invoice No 34508 HEW s counsel charged 3

5 hours for

Preparing memorandum regarding potential claims against People s State Bank 1

5 hours for Preparing draft petition against People s State Bank and 5 hours for Revising drafts of analysis and petition

The Court recognizes that a great deal goes into preparing an analysis as well as a petition It requires reading and considering all applicable law and jurisprudence reading and considering all documents related to the cause of action gathering and assimilating all the facts and circumstances of the case and considering all of these in relation to one another Then it requires actually writing a concise and cogent document in this The amount of time charged in this regard regard in the Court s opinion is modest 5 As to Invoice No 36026 PSB raises only 3 other specific objections PSB objected charges for review and analysis of the Answer preparation of the to corporate deposition notice and preparing for corporate deposition On Invoice No 36026 HEW s counsel charged 2

0 hours specifically for Review and analysis of answer filed by Peoples State Bank meeting with Bernard S Johnson regarding discovery process email correspondence with Jeff Goff Nora Hinton and Gloria Bowden regarding same In regard to the review and analysis of the answer the Court finds that an analysis of the answer that was filed by PSB should have taken additional time because the affirmative defenses were raised without any recitation of purported facts upon which they might be based requiring a lawyer to sift through the facts to try to determine the basis of each such claim In addition this time entry includes other things not referenced in s objection This time PSB charge is not excessive On Invoice No 36026 counsel for HEW charged 2

80 hours specifically for Preparing notice of corporate deposition of Peoples State Bank As in the preparation of a petition or analysis preparation for a corporate deposition requires a review and analysis of all documents factual assertions and law and a consideration of how each may relate to PSB HEW and all of the actors involved in this litigation The Court finds that 2

80 hours is not excessive On Invoice No 36026 counsel for HEW also charged 2

00 hours specifically for Outlining questions for upcoming deposition of Peoples State Bank 3

20 hours for Preparing outline for upcoming deposition of Peoples State Bank and 3

00 hours for Preparing for deposition of

Peoples State Bank and 60 hours for Preparing for deposition of

Peoples State Bank traveling to and from Natchitoches taking deposition of

Peoples State Bank While not expressly listed in the PSB memorandum these charges appear to be the 8

2 hours objected to by PSB for Preparing for corporate deposition

This case is document intensive and the facts conceming the equipment complicated and difficult It takes substantial time to organize and pull together documents to adequately address the issues in this case In addition the charge for 60 hours also includes time for traveling to and from Natchitoches and taking deposition of Peoples State Bank The Court does not find these time charges to be excessive 6 As to Invoice No 36730 PSB raises only 1 other specific objection PSB objected to 2

5 hours charged for

Drafting letter July 13 2009 regarding ATM s counsel charged 2 HEW 5 hours to Prepare letter to Peoples State Bank regarding ATM and inability to be repaired This letter was prepared and written by HEW s counsel at the request of PSB

Again to prepare such a letter requires organizing all the facts and circumstances in light of all information including that which was received in discovery It is time consuming and difficult The work product was excellent It made clear what the difficulties were and the great effort made by HEW to mitigate its damages

The Court does not find this time charge excessive 7 As to Invoice No 38403 PSB raises only 1 other specific objection PSB objected 20 hours charged for Analysis of missed to 0 opportunities s counsel HEW 20 hours for Analysis regarding document charged 0 received from HEW Federal Credit Union regarding missed opportunities for the branch The claim for missed opportunities was rejected as the Court found the claimed losses were far too speculative Consequently the charge for 0

20 hours or 00 is disallowed

40 A 8 As to Invoice No 40893 PSB raises only 1 other specific objection PSB objected to 0 hours

3 charged to Preparation of settlement offer letter December 9 2009 s counsel charged 1 HEW 50 hours for Preparing settlement offer letter to Chris Sylvia and 1

50 hours for Preparing settlement offer letter to Chris Sylvia at Peoples State Bank This letter was prepared and written at the request of PBS and included additional and clarifying information obtained by the parties through discovery and preparation The Court finds these charges reasonable 9 As to Invoice No 42680 PSB raises only l other specific objection PSB objected to 1

40 hours charged to

Drafting written discovery which were not ever actually propounded s counsel charged 1 HEW 40 hours to Draft interrogatories and request for production to defendant Peoples State Bank HEW argues that after a conference between counsel and the Court of 2010 on

January counsel believed that settlement negotiations would take place between HEW and PSB and as a result held off on propounding additional discovery

Such a conference did occur and the Court did encourage PSB to participate in settlement negotiations The decision to hold off on propounding additional discovery was a reasoned decision and an additional effort to resolve the litigation These charges will not be disallowed 10 As to Invoice No 43453 PSB raises only 2 other specific objection PSB

9 hours for Fees charged by Nickelson objected to 7 JCN claiming that an additional attorney working on the lawsuit was not necessary and likely resulted in duplicative work being preformed therefore all of these fees 00 80 should be disallowed PSB also objected to 6 hours

8 7

0020 in fees for or

Deposition preparation HEW was charged 7

9 hours for the work of another attorney JCN as follows a 50 hours for Conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding upcoming trial 2 review pretrial brief 3 b 30 hours for Conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding trial subpoenas and other matters c 20 hours for Conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding upcoming trial and review correspondence from opposing counsel regarding scheduling conference d 50 hours for Conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding settlement and trial strategy e 80 hours for Prepare for trial and conference with Kristi B

Gustavson regarding same f 30 hours for Prepare for trial and conference with

Kristi B Gustavson regarding same g 3 hours for Prepare for trial and conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding same

HEW asserts that JCN was preparing for and performing the cross examination of PSB s chief witness Ms Tori Flynn and that his work was not duplicative of work performed by trial counsel It appears to the Court that a g1 eat deal of time was spent by JCN learning about the facts and circumstances of this case in general information already possessed by Ms Gustavson who was trial counsel i e the numerous conferences with trial counsel and reviewing the same documents that trial counsel would necessarily have to review as well While Ms Gustavson would have had to prepare the cross examination of Tori Flynn she would not have had to learn the facts of the case The Court believes that only 3 hours of the above time charged would have been necessary for Ms Gustavson to accomplish this work Therefore 4 00 in

9 hours or 980 fees are disallowed as duplicative s counsel charged 8 HEW 6 hours for work relating to preparation for trial depositions PSB failed to designate the particular invoice s entries at issue however the Court presumes the following are the entries and charges objected to by PSB a 80 hours for Preparing for upcoming depositions of Diebold and

Advent representatives b 40 hours for Teleconference with James Goldbeck in preparation for trial depositions c 30 hours for Teleconference with Rich

Montague in order to prepare for trial deposition d 30 hours for

Preparing outlines for trial depositions of Diebold and Advent technicians e 00 hours for Preparing for depositions of Bill Weimer Dennis Rainey Rich Montague and James Goldbeck

None of the above charges are objectionable Preparation for trial depositions in this case not only entail knowing the law but also entail being able to deal with the complicated technical facts necessary to try this case 11 As to Invoice No 48109 PSB raises only 1 other specific objection PSB objected to 18

5 hours 00

7 00 charged to Fees charged by Nickelson JCN HEW charged 18

5 hours for the work of another attorney JCN as follows a 50 hours for Prepare for trial including discussion Tori Flynn s examination with Kristi B Gustavson cross b 60 hours for Prepare for trial c 10 hours for Prepare for trial including cross examination of Tori Flynn and conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding same r d 00 hours for Bench trial before

Judge Dee Hawthorne in Natchitoches Louisiana e 30 hours for Conference with Kristi B Gustavson regarding status of settlement discussions with State Bank s People and other matters The Court would note that Mr Nickelson JCN did excellent work and performed well at trial and the Court is convinced that trial counsel appreciated his assistance however much of what he did was necessarily duplicative As explained above JCN had to learn the entire case and spend 10 hours in the court room to primarily cross examine Tori Flynn With her prior knowledge of the case the Court believes that trial counsel could have prepared for Ms s cross

Flynn examination in an additional 5 hours The Court previously allowed 3 hours for Ms Flynn in regard to Invoice No 43453 above Therefore as to Invoice Nno 48109 the Court disallows 5 hours of these charges or 2

7 00 in fees 12 As to Invoice No 44771 PSB raises only 1 specific objection PSB objected to 20 hours charged for Preparation of post trial brief HEW charged 20 hours for work relating to post trial brief preparation as follows a 1

40 hours for

Preparing background facts for post trial brief b 80 hours for Review of trial transcript in order to prepare post trial brief c 2

0 hours for Prepare trial brief post d 00 hours for

Preparing post trial brief regarding legal analysis e 50 hours for

Preparing post trial brief regarding background facts f 50 hours for

Preparing post trial brief regarding legal analysis g 2

80 hours for

Preparing post trial brief regarding analyst sic testimony at trial h 0 hours for issues assertion of facts and conclusions needed to be cited to the transcript This is a lengthy detailed and time consuming process Just reading the transcript and depositions takes hours Counsel for HEW did an excellent job and the Court will not disallow any of this time as unreasonable 13 As to Invoice No 48110 PSB raises only 1 other specific objection PSB objected to 3 hours for Fees charged by Nickelson claiming that an additional attorney working on the lawsuit was not necessary and likely resulted in duplicative work being preformed s counsel charged 0 HEW 30 hours or 60

00 in fees for the work of another attorney JCN for Conference with Kristi B

Gustavson regarding supplemental post trial brief The Court disallows this charge as duplicative and unnecessary

PSB made no other specific objections to the charges on HEW s invoices Additional Charles or Fees Asserted by HEW s argues further that from November HEW

30 2010 to December 16 2010 time incurred by HEW s counsel for preparing for and attending the December 16 h hearing amounted to 2

4 60 of billable time not including preparation time for its post hearing brief which took approximately 2 hours or 400

00 Consequently HEW claims an additional 2

8 60 in s fees attorney

The Court believes these charges to be reasonable Attorney fees determined to be reasonable

HEW seeks reimbursement for attorneys fees actually incurred in the amount of 00 53

56 00 billed and paid and 2

962 860 not yet billed

The Court finds that 18

9 hours at 200 an hour should be disallowed in a total amount of 3

7 80 Without further evaluation that leaves attorney fees in the amount of 53

042 This calculation does not include the request for an estimated future amount of fees netc

The trial judge has great discretion in awarding costs including expel t witness fees deposition costs exhibit costs and related expenses Sz prun v Louisiana Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co

App 1 Cir 4 La 10 2010 WL 1740002 Simpson v Goodman La

App 1 Cir 12

98 727 So

28 2d 555 Absent an abuse of discretion the courts of appeal will not interfere with an award of costs Uela v Plaquemines Parish Government 811 2d 1263 1282

So 2002

C App Lair

The only costs taxable against a litigant are those provided for by positive law Woolen v Lucksinger 14 So

3d 311 l

App La Cir 2008

HEW seeks reimbursement for costs as follows 1 Filing fees 839

00 an additional 425 00 1 2

00 64 2 Long distance telephone charges 205

79 an additional 20 Photocopies 1 40

0 31 an additional 120

00 1 40 51 4 Mileage 307

50 an additional 75 00 382

5 Westlaw Legal Research 2 90

8 53 an additional 108 2 61

6 Courier Fee 70 7 Court Reporter Fees 8 Trial subpoena cost 325 9 Custom tabs index tabs binding 22

10 Federal Express 80 11 Conference Call Charges 13 12 Trial transcript 477 13 Meals for KBG and JCN 22 for a total of 7

8 89 The Court finds the following listed expenses are disallowed since these charges are not provided for by law 2 of the photocopy charge 575

70 all of the Westlaw charge

261 all of the courier fee 70

00 all of the Federal Express charges 80

20 and 2 of the meals charges 00 for a total of disallowed charges in the amount of

3 98 The Court allowed of the t photocopy charges because this case involved so many copies and many were used in the trial of the matter

HEW seeks reimbursement for costs in the amount of 7

8 89 The Court finds that 3

6 98 should be disallowed Without further evaluation that leaves costs in the amount of 4

91 The Court finds these reasonable and allowed according to law Other considerations

PSB argues that any fees or costs relating to HEW s claim for lost income should be disallowed because the plaintiff was not successful in regard to this claim at trial the court having found that any such loss was not reasonably quantifiable Very little time was spent addressing this issue at trial and only one witness testified concerning this claim The Court will not reduce the fees in this regard

The final consideration by this Court is the main argument made by PSB whether the amount awarded as s fees should be completely driven by the attorney amount finally awarded on the substantive claim 13

This Court finds that it should not be so driven in this case under these circumstances The Court finds that PSB in large part is the cause for delaying resolution of this matter and for the amount of s fees attorney and costs necessitated and ultimately expended in this litigation

HEW purchased a mobile banking unit MBU from PSB The ATM machine built in the MBU was not the product advertised and the ATM that was there was inoperable and irreparable PSB personnel had all of the information it needed to make this determination at the time of the sale HEW was forced to hire an attorney to represent its interests PSB has paid no extra s fees as it was represented by in attorney house counsel As the result of the diligent efforts of HEW and its retained counsel PSB was urgently advised of the problems and the defect at issue even before the suit was filed and before any significant fees and costs were incurred

HEW could have successfully urged a claim for return of the purchase price of 115

00 because the MBU was clearly not fit for its intended use without a working or reparable ATM HEW was faced with a dilemma when PSB refused to make good on its sale At that point in addition to the costs associated with the sale itself HEW had invested additional money preparing the MBU for HE W s use i e having it custom painted with its logo and other installation In expenses addition HEW could not afford to buy a new MBU HEW could have pursued its claim for the return of the purchase price all costs relating to sale and all of the expenses involved in preparing the MBU for HEW s use However when PSB refused to make good on the sale in an effort to mitigate its losses HEW personnel searched diligently to find a replacement for the defective ATM It was not a simple feat as there were extreme space limitations and most companies could not provide such a product HEW finally found a company that could provide a replacement and it made the purchase

PSB was offered the opportunity to simply pay for the replacement however PSB would not respond at all to any of HEW s proposals or attempts to settle the case On several occasions throughout the litigation PSB specifically requested that HEW prepare and submit to them settlement proposals Each time PSB requested it HEW did so it made the proposal and provided the factual and legal argument supporting its proposal This was confirmed at the January status conference when counsel for PSB reported that no answer had been made to HE W in regard to any of its settlement proposals The Court strongly encouraged PSB to participate in efforts to settle this litigation It is clear that at each step in this process PSB has been aware of the facts sufficient to know that the ATM was not the product advertised and that the ATM was defective inoperable and irreparable Instead PSB chose to forego actively pursuing a settlement and instead relied on its chances at trial HEW was forced to continue to incur s fees and costs attorney

The purpose of the statutory authority to award attorneys fees and costs is to make the buyer whole In a redhibition action reasonable s fees should be attorney awarded to justly compensate plaintiffs who succeed in establishing liability on the part of the seller or manufacturer under Louisiana Civil Code article 2545 Linoski et al v Fleetwood Homes of Texas et al 38

338 La App 2 Cir 5

1 2 873 So 2d 886

Conclusion

Consequently the Court awards all the attorney s fees and costs incurred thus far and not disallowed by the Court herein 53 y0 and 4 042 19 respectively The Court will not award an anticipated amount for future fees and costs at this time s counsel is to HEW prepare the judgment in accordance with this ruling which will be signed upon presentation WRITTEN REASONS FOR RULING RENDERED IN

CHAMBERS at Natchitoches Natchitoches Parish Louisiana on the day of February 2010

DEE A HAWTH

RNE DISTRICT JtTDGE DIVISION B

1 Neither the underlying award for damages nor the award for costs is challenged on appeal. 2 1 00 PSB claimed that 900 00 of these charges should be disallowed The Court has reviewed this invoice and cannot find such charges The only entry 5 Preparing and finalizing post trial brief At the conclusion of the trial of this matter counsel for PSB requested that a transcript of the trial be prepared and the Court ordered detailed briefing There were several legal issues that the Court wanted the attorneys to specifically address In addition the case was fact intensive and the Court wanted the facts specifically argued in the briefs In the Court s view any briefing on factual

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.