Webb v. Halliburton Oil Well Cementing Co.
Webb v. Halliburton Oil Well Cementing Co.
Opinion of the Court
These are suits against defendant Halliburton Oil Well Cementing Company, and its insurer, Continental Casualty Company, for damages alleged to have been inflicted upon plaintiffs in a collision of an automobile in which they were riding, with a truck belonging to the insured. The cases were consolidated for trial and tried by a jury which returned verdicts in favor of each plaintiff for identical sums of $17,000 each.
Defendants have moved for judgment in their favor notwithstanding the verdicts and, in the alternative, for new trials.
Atkins was the owner and driver of the car, and Webb was his guest. The automobile ran into the rear of a truck headed in the same direction and on the same side of the paved highway in which the plaintiffs were traveling. The latter contended the truck was moving slowly at the time and that another truck belonging to the insured suddenly flashed on its lights, which blinded the driver of the automobile, causing him to run into the rear end of the first truck; while defendants claim that the truck was parked disabled, partly on the
There should be judgment in favor of defendants on his demand.
Webb, as stated,, was a guest, and the circumstances disclosed by the evidence do not, in this court’s opinion, show him to have been in any sense responsible for the accident. If the first or loaded truck was parked where it stood, then it was a jury question as to whether the lights, flares, etc., were set out and burning; and this has been decided adversely to the defendants, which likewise makes them guilty of negligence which concurred with that of Atkins to cause Webb’s injury, thereby rendering them solidarity liable, for such damages as were proven. It is the opinion of this court, however, that the amount allowed by the jury was greatly excessive, in view of the nature and extent of Webb’s injuries shown by the evidence, and that the sum of $7000 would amply compensate him for the same. Unless this complainant shall enter a remittitur of the amount by which the verdict exceeds the sum of $7000, within twenty (20) days, a new trial will be granted.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- WEBB v. HALLIBURTON OIL WELL CEMENTING CO. ATKINS v. HALLIBURTON OIL WELL CEMENTING CO.
- Status
- Published