Hunter's Syndics v. Hunter
Hunter's Syndics v. Hunter
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court. Having doubted the correctness of our opinion, and the judgment heretofore rendered in this case, we granted a rehearing, at
The sole question in the cause is, whether the bond, on which the action is founded, has been forfeited, so as to make the obligors liable for its penalty? The condition on which the obligation was to have been avoided, is to to have a certain negro (therein mentioned) or his value forthcoming, to answer any judgment that might be rendered in a case then pending in the district court, against one of the obligors, and another person. The decree of the court in that case was, that said negro should be delivered to the appellants, who were plaintiffs in the former case, as well as in this. They rely much for a change of our judgment, on the 35th law of the 11th tit. Part. 5; in which it is clearly laid down, that, where a man promises to give or to do any thing, under a certain penalty, and on a day fixed, the obligee has a right to claim either the penalty or the specific performance of the thing, at his option. When no day certain is fixed, the obligor, should it be required of him by the other party, at a proper time and place, and he refuse, when it was in his power to have fulfilled his promise; or if
The notice of the judgment was given to both the obligors on the same day, viz. 17th of November last. Bennet, from whom the fulfilment of the condition of the bond was demanded, did not refuse to comply; neither does it appear that Hunter refused. We have no doubt but that a tender or delivery of the negro to the sheriff, in discharge of the first judgment, if made in any reasonable time, and before suit actually commenced on the bond, would release the obligors. It does not appear that any request was made on Hunter to deliver the negro, or if it was, the time is not shewn. Bennet, on receiving notice of the judgment, and being required to cause a performance of the condition of his bond, offered at once to comply; but seems, on account of some cause not stated by the
Reference
- Full Case Name
- HUNTER'S SYNDICS v. HUNTER
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published