Morgan v. Robinson
Morgan v. Robinson
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
In support of this judgment the appellee relies on the limitation provided against this species of action by the Civil Code, 358, art. 75, wherein it is declared in positive terms, that whether the object of the suit be to cancel the contract, or to have the price reduced, it ought to be instituted within six months from the date of the sale at the farthest, or from the time that the defects or vices have been discovered; provided, that in this latter case not more than one year has elapsed from the time of sale, and after that term the buyer shall not be admitted to said action.
It is shewn by the evidence in the cause
He relies principally on the maxim, "contra non valentem agere, non currit prescriptio:" as adopted and recognized by the Spanish law, and being an axiom or first principle of natural law and justice, and therefore applicable to every system of jurisprudence, wherein the contrary is not expressly established by legislative power. In this view of the subject we agree with the counsel of the plaintiff, and, notwithstanding the express terms of limitation in our code, it is thought, that they ought not to be interpreted as to conflict with this universal maxim of justice. The time prescribed by law for commencing a redhibitory action, is six months from the date of the sale, or six months from the discovery of the defects and recovery of the things sold. In the present case, it is shewn that the defendant
It is therefore ordered, adjudged and decreed, that the judgment of the district court be avoided, reversed and annulled, and that the bail bond be restored to its full force, &c. And it is further ordered, adjudged and decreed, that this cause be remanded to said district court to be there tried on its merits; as in the opinion of this court, sufficient matter does not appear on the record on which to decide the cause finally, among other deficiencies, there is no evidence to shew the comparative value of the slaves complained of in
Martin, J did not sit in this case, having considered the question arising therein, at a time when he had a deep interest in it.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- MORGAN v. ROBINSON
- Status
- Published