Trepagnier's Heirs v. Butler
Trepagnier's Heirs v. Butler
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court. In this case the plaintiffs claim title to the land described in their petition, as heirs to their father. They state, in an amendment to the pleadings, that he disappeared in the year 1799, and has not since been heard of. The right of the ancestor to the property in dispute, is not contested; as the defendants claim by virtue of title derived from him, through Mad. Trepagnier, the mother of the plaintiffs, to whom it is alleged to have been adjudicated by a competent tribunal of the Spanish government, while in the exercise of rightful sovereignty and jurisdiction over this country.
The first and most important inquiry, necessary to a just decision of the cause, relates to the conclusiveness of that adjudication, on the rights of the present contending parties. The manner in which it was made, and the evidence on which the proceeding of the Spanish tribunal were founded, do not fully appear, in consequence of the loss of the record, which contained that history. To sup
As the judgment, by which Mad. Trepagnier acquired title to the property now in dispute, is not open to examination, the evidence on which it was based, is no more subject to review than the law. Every thing must be presumed to have been properly conducted, and that Trepagnier was, quoad the proceedings in that case dead in 1799.
The widow, who sold to the defendants, having acquired the property by the adjudication of the Spanish tribunal, and having re
It is therefore ordered, adjudged and decreed, that said judgment be affirmed with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- TREPAGNIER'S HEIRS v. BUTLER & AL.
- Status
- Published