Roman Catholic Church v. Miller
Roman Catholic Church v. Miller
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court. The plaintiffs claim $500, under a
The appellees prayed for a dismissal of the appeal for want of a statement of facts, done in due time. There is no statement of facts, but a certificate of the judge of probates, several months after the judgment, attesting the record contains all the proceedings and evidence adduced on the trial.
We think this suffices: The act of 1820 requires that all the testimony given at the trial of a cause in the court of probates, shall at the time be reduced to writing, to serve as a statement of facts. This being the case, and there appearing depositions of witnesses, we must conclude that all the evidence was reduced to writing. And the transcript of the record duly certified, enables us to examine the merits of the case, and this certificate may be made after the judgment.
The plaintiff’s legacy is a particular one. The legacy of the property I possess in such a place, is a particular one. 5 Toulier 487 & 5 4. And the nature of the legacy is not varied because a sum of money is bequeathed. A legacy of one hundred reals, which I have in such a box, is good for so much as the testator has there, up to that sum. 1 Febrero e. 2, § 2, p 24. And we have received from Spain a positive legislative provision on this respect. Part 6, 9, 18. Mor. & Car. 962.
We think the judge ought to have restrained the legacy to the money found in the designated drawer.
It is therefore ordered, adjudged and decreed, that the judgment be annulled, avoided and reversed, and that there be judgment in favor of the plaintiffs for one hundred and seventy dollars and two cents, with interest from the judicial demand, with costs in the
Reference
- Full Case Name
- ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH v. MILLER
- Status
- Published