Sterling v. Drew
Sterling v. Drew
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court. The plaintiffs in this case claim title to a certain tract of land described in their petition. The defendant, Drew, disclaimed any right to the property, and the inhabitants of the parish of Ouachita were permitted to interfere in the suit, and become de
The title set up by the latter is founded on an incomplete grant from the Spanish government to one Epinette, who conveyed his right to the Baron de Bastrop, from whom the title has been transmitted to the appellants, through several mesne conveyances, and has been recognised and confirmed by the United States.
The defendants claim title to the premises in dispute as having been set apart for the use of the parish, to be employed in public purposes, such as a burying ground and site for a church. This claim has been also confirmed by the government of the United States.
In support of the plaintiffs’ title, prescription is relied on as based on possession of ten years, and in their claim this must also be taken into view.
In the act of sale from Epinette to Bastrop, the land sold is limited by that now claimed by the defendants. All the subsequent deeds embrace it within these limits. Possession since the year 1810 is proven
It then only remains to examine their pretentions, as supported by other evidences of title. These are the deeds of sale above stated, and they do not ascend so as to shew any concession, even of the most imperfect and inchoate kind, from the Spanish government, which, includes the land in dispute.—It is true that this property has been relinquished and confirmed to them by the succeeding government, but it has also been relinquished and confirmed to the defendants. The respective claims and rights of both parties to the suit, rest on the titles which were obtained from the Spanish government, and if they be not equally weak and without foundation, we are of opinion that the preponderance is in favor of that relied on by the defendants, as it is shewn that the disputed ground was laid off and set apart for the use of the inhabitants of the parish.
It is therefore ordered, adjudged and de
Reference
- Full Case Name
- STERLING & WIFE v. DREW & AL.
- Status
- Published