Green v. Davis
Green v. Davis
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court. This suit is founded on a promissory note, by which it appears that the defendants agreed to pay to the plaintiff, in his capacity of executor, the sum of 650 dollars.— Their answer does not deny the execution of the note, or justice of the claim made on the part of the plaintiff; but contains a plea of compensation, in support of which they allege several sums of money to be due to them from the testator and his executor. The principal item in support’of the plea of compensation was rejected by the court below ; and the defendants, dissatisfied with the judgment which was rendered, appealed.
According to the judgment of the court of probates above cited, the appellee could not have paid, with propriety, the whole debt due to the appellant, Davis. The latter was bound to await a just and full administration of the estate managed by the former in his capacity of executor, and receive payment from him according to a legal distribution of the funds in his possession.
To give effect to the compensation thus offered, would be contrary to the very evidence which establishes the debt due from the succession of the testator to one of the defendants; and in violation of the justice and equity inculcated by our laws on the subject of successions.
The note of the testator, dated in 1823, and transferred by endorsement to Davis, ought not to have been admitted in compensation. The present suit is brought on a promise made to the executor, in consideration of property purchased by the defendants at the sale of Dunlap’s succession. If creditors of
It is, therefore, ordered, adjudged, and decreed, that the judgment of the district court be avoided, reversed, and annulled; and it is further ordered, adjudged, and decreed, that the plaintiff and appellee do recover from the defendants and appellants six hundred and fifty dollars, with interest at the rate of five percent, per annum from the judicial demand until paid, and costs in both courts.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- GREEN v. DAVIS & AL.
- Status
- Published