Pilie v. Lalande
Pilie v. Lalande
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the . . This is an action of redhibition. The pleaded the general issue. The ° slave was sold as a washer, ironer and cook. Th° evidence shews that she possessed these qualities very defectively, if at all. The jury found a verdict for the plaintiff, reducing the price $170. The defendants have appealed, and the plaintiff has required that the judgment be amended, by the court decreeing a. recission of the sale.
The evidence is contradictory, and does not authorize us to disturb the verdict. The only questions which require our particular attention, are those presented by two bills of exceptions, taken on the trial by the defendants.
The second bill of exceptions was to the admission of a witness offered by the plaintiff. The defendant objected to her, on the ground that she was a slave. The court considered the actual enjoyment of freedom by the witness as prima facie evidence of her competency. The bill of exceptions does not state whether she was a negro, or mulatto. If the latter, the presumption was in favor of her being free, and the court did not err in admitting
It is therefore ordered, adjudged and decreed, that the judgment of the district court be affirmed, with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- PILIE v. LALANDE & AL.
- Status
- Published