Brickell v. Frisby
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Kellogg v. Steamboat T. D. Hine (La. 1867)
- Western Marine & Fire Insurance v. Casselly (La. 1844)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This is an action by the owners of the steamboat Commerce to recover damages of the owners of the steamboat Lady of Lyons, alleged to have been caused by a collision in the Mississippi river, by the fault of the officers and crew of the latter boat; and the plaintiffs are appellants from a judgment in favor of the defendants.
We are in the habit of attaching great importance to the decisions of the courts of the first instance in matters of fact, and never reverse them, unless convinced there has been manifest error. Cases like the present, however, differ materially from ordinary ones. Whenever a collision has taken place, the first inquiry is, was it a mere accident — a fortuiious event ? If so, the misfoiv
Notwithstanding the conflicting testimony in the case, three things are incontestibly proved : First, that the Commerce was of superior speed, and at no time out of the line which it had a right to pursue, and might have pursued with safety if the Lady of Lyons had not deviated from her course. Second, That at the moment of the collision, the Commerce was in the act of sheering off to avoid the blow, which she received obliquely, at an angle of about thirty-five degrees with the other boat, about the wheel-house. Third, That the Lady of Lyons sheered off three different times from her course, so as to run ahead of the Commerce. She was running round a point in rather shallow water, and the Commerce was near the middle of the river.
On the part of the Commerce there was, therefore, the absence of every imaginable motive to run afoul of the other boat. She was able at any moment to pass her, and had done so some days before. On the other hand, there seems to have been, on the part of some of the persons employed on the Lady of Lyons, a disposition to keep ahead, and to thwart the other boat, and prevent her passing. One of the engineers on board the Lady of Lyons very candidly states that, “ from the time they left the wood-yard until the collision took place, the Commerce was endeavoring to pass the Lady of Lyons, and we were using all endeavors, as far as our safety permitted, not to let her, and we were keeping as near as could be to the sand-bar; so much so, that at one time I thought she would run on it.”
It was in this situation of things, that the Lady of Lyons sheer*
It is, therefore, adjudged and decreed that the judgment of the' District Court be reversed; that the cause be remanded for a new trial; and that the appellees pay the costs of the appeal.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.