Second Municipality v. Caldwell
Second Municipality v. Caldwell
Opinion of the Court
James H. Caldwell is appellant from a judgment
The record contains the following admissions : 1st. That the notes sued upon were given for the lease of certain lots in the city of New Orleans, leased by the defendants from the plaintiffs. 2d. That at the time of the lease, the defendants were Aldermen of the Second Municipality. 3d. That the property was leased for a term of years, not yet expired.
Under the above admissions, it is contended that the contract of lease, in consideration of which the notes sued on were given, is absolutely void, as the defendants, who were Aldermen at the time the notes were executed, were incapacitated by law from entering into such contract with the plaintiffs ; and in support of this position, we are referred to the fourth section of a law of the 14th of March, 1816, (Bullard & Curry’s Dig. p. 102, § 35,) which says, that “ in future, the Mayor, Recorder, nor any of the Aldermen then in office, shall be allowed, either in his own name, or through the medium of other persons, to become the lessee or bidder for any branch of the revenues of the city, nor for any work or undertaking whatever, which may be authorized, or ordered by the corporation of said city.” The French text of the law is : “ ne pourra se rendre fermier, ou adjudicataire de la perception d’aucune branche des revenus de la ville.”
We think the law relied on by the defendants does not cover the present case. It is true it incapacitates the Mayor, Recorder and Aldermen from becoming the lessees or bidders for any branch of the revenues of the city, but it seems to us that its terms cannot be so construed or extended, as to prohibit them from leasing any lot of ground or other property of the city. Although revenue may be derived from the leasing of such property, surely, it cannot be said that they become lessees of a whole branch of the revenue. We understand the expressions used in the law, which in the French text are very clear, to mean that a branch of the revenue, that is to say, the collection of any species of revenue, which, with the other branches, is to form the whole annual in
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- The Second Municipality of New Orleans v. James H. Caldwell and another
- Status
- Published