Graneri v. Talbot
Graneri v. Talbot
Opinion of the Court
The petitioner having paid as endorser, a note drawn to his order by Adolphe Legendre, seeks to recover its amount from Lavinia Robertson, formerly the wife of Legendre, but now married to Augustus Talbot, and from her brother James Robertson. He alleges, that as this note had been given in payment of a store account, the divers items of which were articles of female ornament and apparel she had bought for her exclusive use, she and her brother and co-defendant promised and assumed to pay the same for the honor of the family. Interrogatories were propounded to the defendants, in answer to which they both denied ever having promised to pay the note, or any part of the account for which it was given. No attempt was made to contradict Mrs. Talbot’s answers, and she is clearly not bound. The . debt was contracted by her first husband; and it is not shown that she has done any act to render herself liable for the debts of the community since its dissolution. As relates to her co-defendant, James Robertson, four witnesses were examined to disprove his answers on oath. One of them is not certain whether it was the defendant, or Win. Robertson, who said he would pay the note. Another witness, Holmes, says, that defendant said he would see the note paid to the plaintiff, and also that he would attend to its payment. Monget says defendant did promise to pay the amount of the note to the plaintiff; and according to Bon-necaze, the last witness, the defendant said the note would be paid by the family, and not to be uneasy about the payment of it. These various statements, although vague as to time and place, might perhaps have sufficed to show a promise to pay on the part of the defendant; but they disagree with a declaration made by the plaintiff himself, and which is testified to by two witnesses
Testimony offered to disprove the answers on oath, of a party interrogated upon facts and articles, should be positive and free from uncertainty.
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Michel Graneri v. Lavinia Talbot and another
- Status
- Published