Zagame v. Chalmette Laundry Co.

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Zagame v. Chalmette Laundry Co., 142 La. 251 (La. 1917)
76 So. 703; 1917 La. LEXIS 1662
Decree, Niell, Sommervtlle

Zagame v. Chalmette Laundry Co.

Opinion of the Court

SOMMERVTLLE, J.

This is a suit sounding in damages by a landlady against her tenant, .based on torts said to have been committed by the tenant during the pendency of the lease. She alleges that she rented a certain lot belonging to her in the city of New Orleans to the defendant for a rental of $5 per month, the lease to continue for one year. She also alleges that during the pendency of the lease the defendant destroyed a stable and concrete floor on the lot worth $175, for which she claims damages in the sum of $175. She makes a further claim for $2,500, based on an alleged invasion of the property by the lessee during the pendency of the lease, and for a trespass thereupon, referring to the alleged destruction of the stable and concrete floor referred to above.

Defendant excepted to the petition on the grounds that it disclosed no cause of action, and that the demand was premature.

There was judgment sustaining the exception of prematurity, and plaintiff has appealed.

The claim for $2,500 damages based upon an alleged trespass upon and invasion of the property by the tenant leased by it from the plaintiff is so greatly inflated and unreasonable that the court will take cognizance thereof and transfer this appeal, as the claim must necessarily be for less than $2,000, and this court is without jurisdiction.

The claim for $2,500 appears to be based on the destruction of the stable and concrete floor, which plaintiff alleges cost $175, and for the cost of which she has also made demand in this suit.

It is therefore ordered, adjudged, and decreed that this case be transferred to the Court of Appeal for the parish of Orleans, to be there proceeded with in accordance with law.

O’NIELL, J., concurs in the decree.

Reference

Full Case Name
ZAGAME v. CHALMETTE LAUNDRY CO.
Cited By
2 cases
Status
Published
Syllabus
(Syllabus ly the Court.) Courts The Supreme Court shall have appellate jurisdiction only where the matter in dispute or the fund to be distributed shall exceed $2,000, etc.