Bilich v. Mathe
Bilich v. Mathe
Opinion of the Court
On Motion to Dismiss Appeal.
The motion to dismiss the appeal is overruled.
On Motion to Eliminate Depositions from the Record.
Certain documents annexed to appellee’s motion would show a very plausible reason why the depositions were not offered in evidence, if we could consider the documents as evidence before us. The only method by which we could get such documents before-us as evidence would be to remand the case for a trial of this motion. Such a proceeding is unnecessary, because the fact that the depositions were not offered in evidence is a sufficient reason for our eliminating and excluding them from the record.
The transcript is so arranged and bound that it would be quite difficult to take the-depositions out without mutilating the record. It will suffice for the clerk of this court to mark the depositions referred to so that the court will not forget that they are not to be considered as evidence in the case.
It is ordered that the depositions of the six witnesses referred to herein be eliminated and excluded from the transcript of appeal and be not considered as evidence in. the case.
Opinion on the Merits
“Their testimony is so thoroughly inconsistent with truth and logic that the court expresses surprise that such litigation should have been instituted.”
The evidence as a whole leaves no doubt at all that the child ran off the sidewalk against the side of the automobile which was within a foot or two of the curb, and fell under the hind wheel. On his forehead was a gash, which indicated that his head must have struck against the fender of the car.
The judgment, dismissing the suit, is affirmed, with costs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- BILICH et ux. v. MATHE
- Cited By
- 16 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- (Syllabus by Editorial Staff.) 1. Appeal and error In view of Act No. 112 of 1916, § 9, appeal will not be dismissed for any inaccuracy or error in the appeal bond or for insufficiency of security, where the defendant has not been put in default in the district court in the manner directed by the statute. On Motion to Eliminate Depositions from the Record. 2. Appeal and error &wkey;*837(IO) — Depositions in record but not in evidence cannot be considered on appeal. Depositions in the record on appeal not offered in evidence cannot be considered in deciding the ease upon its merits, and a motion to eliminate them will be allowed. On the Merits. 3. Municipal corporations 706(6) — Evidence in action for death by being run over by automobile held to warrant dismissing the case. In an action against an automobile driver for the death of plaintiff’s six year old boy by being run over, evidence held such as to warrant dismissing case.