Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1983

McCarter v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

McCarter v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.
Supreme Court of Louisiana · Decided November 4, 1983 · Dennis, Dixon, Grant, Lemmon, Writ
440 So. 2d 145 (Southern Reporter, Second Series)

McCarter v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.

Concurring Opinion

DIXON, C.J., and LEMMON, J.,

agree that the writ should be denied. The Court of Appeal, 436 So.2d 726, was probably in error on the jury question, but relator makes no showing that the Court of Appeal was wrong on the merits.

Opinion of the Court

In Re: Renna McCarter, applying for Supervisory writ of Certiorari, Mandamus and Review to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal, Number CA-0699; Civil District Court Parish of Orleans, Number 80-15695.

Deniedi The regult ⅛ correct

DENNIS, J., would grant the writ.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.