Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1984

Carbonell v. Department of Health & Human Resources, Office of Mental Health & Substance Abuse

Carbonell v. Department of Health & Human Resources, Office of Mental Health & Substance Abuse
Supreme Court of Louisiana · Decided March 16, 1984 · Lemmon
447 So. 2d 1063; 1984 La. LEXIS 8576 (Southern Reporter, Second Series)

Carbonell v. Department of Health & Human Resources, Office of Mental Health & Substance Abuse

Opinion of the Court

In re Marta R. Carbonell, applying for Writ of Certiorari or Review to the First Circuit Court of Appeal, Number 83-CA-0186, from Department of State Civil Service, Number 2235.

Denied.

Concurring Opinion

LEMMON, J.,

concurs, but disagrees with the standard stated by the court of appeal for reviewing Civil Service Commission decisions based on taped testimony. The function of the Commission is to find facts; and the reviewing court should not perform the same function again, but should accept those factual findings which are supported by the evidence.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.