Apolinar v. Professional Construction Services, Inc.
Apolinar v. Professional Construction Services, Inc.
Opinion of the Court
In re Alfredo Apolinar, et al.; Plaintiffs); applying for rehearing of this Court’s Order dated September 26, 1997; to the Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit No. 96CA-1492; Parish of Orleans, Civil District Court, Division “A”, No. 94-8838.
Prior report: 701 So.2d 964.
Rehearing Denied.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting from refusal to grant rehearing.
I would grant the rehearing and docket the case for briefing and oral argument for two reasons.
First, this court’s recurring practice by which a court majority reverses a court of appeal decision summarily (and, in this case, without even so much as a stated reason) is hardly defensible. See Day v. Delchamps, Inc., 97-1244 (La. 9/19/97), 701 So.2d 178; Super Stop Enterprises, Inc. v. Alcoholic Beverage Control Bd., 97-1128 (La. 6/30/97), 696 So.2d 1373. Ours is not an error correction court, but a court of last resort whose main function is to guide the jurisprudence and decide important legal issues.
Second, I believe that the court of appeal was correct when it held that the numerosity and common character requirements necessary for preliminary certification of a class action were established. The potential class consists of as many as 136 claimants. PCS
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Alfredo APOLINAR v. PROFESSIONAL CONSTRUCTION SERVICES, INC.
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published