State v. Blanchard

Supreme Court of Louisiana
State v. Blanchard, 717 So. 2d 1126 (La. 1998)
1998 La. LEXIS 2481; 1998 WL 470585
Date, Grant, Incarceration, Johnson, Kimball, Lemmon, Marcus, Reason, Reducer, Sentence, Writ

State v. Blanchard

Opinion of the Court

In re Blanchard, Jodie; — Defendant(s); applying for supervisory and/or remedial writs; Parish of Jefferson, 24th Judicial District Court, Div. “N”, Nos. 96-3932, 96-3933; to the Court of Appeal, Fifth Circuit, No. 98-KW-0763.

Writ denied. Relator’s claim is presently pending in the district court, therefore it is premature.

MARCUS, J., would grant the writ and reducer the sentence to 30 days from date of incarceration (July 14,1998). LEMMON, J., not on panel.

Concurring Opinion

KIMBALL, J.,

concurs in denying the writ, because the issue is premature, but would order the trial court to act on the motion for reconsideration within 48 hours.

JOHNSON, J., dissents and assigns reason.

Dissenting Opinion

JOHNSON, Justice,

dissenting.

Both the defendant and her husband were arrested on drug charges. On the date of her trial, defendant failed to appear because she drove her husband to federal prison. When she voluntarily appeared before the trial court the next day, she was found guilty of contempt of court and was sentenced to the maximum sentence of six months.

All of the drug charges against defendant were subsequently dismissed. Consequently, the only basis for her incarceration at this time is contempt of court. Defendant filed a Motion to Reconsider Sentence, which the trial court took under advisement with no indication as to when a judgment will be rendered. I do not feel that defendant should be denied relief at this time on the basis that the Motion to Reconsider Sentence is still pending in the trial court, because she may continue to be incarcerated for an un-determinable period of time while the trial court has the motion under advisement.

In my view, to keep defendant incarcerated for contempt of court is unconscionable under these circumstances, particularly since the underlying criminal charges have been dismissed. I would therefore grant the writ and order the release of defendant pending further proceedings.

Reference

Full Case Name
STATE of Louisiana v. Jodie BLANCHARD
Status
Published