Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2013

Sterbcow v. Sherman

Sterbcow v. Sherman
Supreme Court of Louisiana · Decided March 22, 2013 · Assigns, Grant, Hughes, Reasons
110 So. 3d 548; 2013 WL 1568026; 2013 La. LEXIS 676 (Southern Reporter, Third Series)

Sterbcow v. Sherman

Dissenting Opinion

HUGHES, J.

dissenting.

I respectfully dissent and would grant the writ. The district court made a finding Ms. Gervais was unavailable to testify at trial. Although plaintiff was not present at Ms. Gervais’ deposition, plaintiffs insurer, a party with a similar interest to that of plaintiff, was present at the deposition. Therefore, the hearsay exception set forth in La.Code Evid. Art. 804(B)(1) is applicable. Accordingly, I would reverse the judgment of the district court, which granted plaintiffs motion in limine to exclude Ms. Gervais’ testimony.

Opinion of the Court

In re National Fire and Marine Insurance Company; Sherman, Lisa Fasola;— Defendant(s); Applying For Supervisory and/or Remedial Writs, Parish of Orleans, Civil District Court Div. L, No. 2004-8206; to the Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit, No. 2013-C-0355.

Denied.

HUGHES, J., would grant and assigns written reasons.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.