Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2016

In re Grand Jury Proceedings

In re Grand Jury Proceedings
Supreme Court of Louisiana · Decided July 27, 2016 · Grant, Knoll, Reasons
195 So. 3d 1206; 2016 WL 4265056 (Southern Reporter, Third Series)

In re Grand Jury Proceedings

Opinion of the Court

In re State of Louisiana; — Other; Applying For Writ of Certiorari and/or Review, Parish of Orleans, Criminal District Court Div. B, No. 33289-16; to the Court *1207of Appeal, Fourth Circuit, No. 2016-K-0751.

|,Writ denied.

Dissenting Opinion

KNOLL, J.,

would grant and assigns reasons.

hi vote to grant and reversé the lower courts’ rulings in accordance with my dissent to this Court’s writ denial in State v. Pittman, 16-1284, — So.3 — (La.7/14/16). The lower courts erred in granting the State’s subpoena request for records from the Department of Children and Family Services relating to non-validated eases. The Court of Appeal’s ruling, allowing the records to be produced for in camera inspection, ignores the plain language of La. Ch.C. art. 615(E), which expressly provides that the records in non-validated cases “shall not be disclosed or ordered to be produced in conjunction with any legal proceeding or other matter,” (Emphasis added). Thus, I would deny the State’s request to subpoena these records.

KNOLL, J., would grant and assigns reasons.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.