Moran v. Desmond
Cases that cite this one
2 later published cases cite this decision.
- Guardianship of Freida (Mass. App. Ct. 1997)
- Dente v. Pink (Mass. App. Ct. 1977)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
1. We are not persuaded by any of the reasons advanced by the former wards for disturbing the decree of the Probate Court in so far as it allowed the charges for services rendered by the guardian’s wife. The charges were not objectionable on the ground that some or all of them may have been paid from principal rather than income. Newhall, Settlement of Estates, § 389, at 552-553 (4th ed. 1958). See Dawes v. Howard, 4 Mass. 97, 99 (1808); Commonwealth v. Graham, 157 Mass. 73, 76 (1892); Hale v. Gravallese, 340 Mass. 722 (1960). The contention that their inclusion in the guardian’s amended accounts was an afterthought, and therefore improper because not based on any prior understanding, is sufficiently answered by the records the wife maintained for the guardian from the outset and by the unamended accounts periodically filed by him on the basis of those records, which included those charges (though in a slightly greater aggregate amount and in the form of food and utilities rather than cash) and demonstrate that neither the guardian nor his wife ever intended her services to be gratuitous. See Melanefy v. O’Driscoll, 164 Mass. 422, 423 (1895). Compare Thurston v. Perry, 130 Mass. 240, 241-242 (1881); Macomber v. King, 288 Mass. 381, 383 (1934), and cases cited. Contrast Mulhern v. McDavitt, 16 Gray 404 (1860); Shurtleff v. Rile, 140 Mass. 213, 215-216 (1885). The general finding of the auditor (facts final) that the amounts so charged were “reasonable and proper and constitute [d] fair compensation for the services she rendered to the Desmond children” was obviously based in large measure on subsidiary facts not expressly found by him as to the amount of time spent by the wife in performing each of the services in question and the dates on which she performed them and, because the wards filed no objection to that general finding nor any motion to recommit for the purpose of obtaining further subsidiary findings relative thereto, we are bound by it. Bills v. Nunno, ante, 279, 281-283 (1976), and cases cited. The wards’ remaining arguments concerning the wife’s charges are completely without merit. 2. The con
So ordered.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.