Commonwealth v. Vines
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Commonwealth v. Kaio D. Rodrigues Da Silva. (Mass. App. Ct. 2025)
- DOMINION BUILDERS, LLC v. HENNEP PROPERTIES LLC & Others. (Mass. App. Ct. 2025)
- Commonwealth v. Armen Agabalian. (Mass. App. Ct. 2024)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion
*690 Following his convictions 2 by a jury in the Superior Court, the defendant, Brian Vines, filed a notice of appeal and, subsequently, a series of motions seeking, inter alia, certain information about the jurors seated in his trial, for use in support of a motion for postconviction relief. In his first motion, the defendant sought the names, addresses, and dates of birth of the jurors. The motion was allowed as to the names of the jurors *691 only. 3 Approximately five months later, a different attorney filed what he captioned a "Renewed Motion of the Defendant for the Release of Juror Information" seeking the same information as the first motion. After the Commonwealth filed its opposition, the defendant filed a reply memorandum clarifying that he was seeking the addresses and the dates of birth of the jurors that were seated in his case based on the list of jurors in the venire who appeared for jury selection at that time of his trial. After a hearing, the motion was denied and the defendant noticed an appeal from the order. The defendant then filed a motion for reconsideration, which was denied, and he also appealed from that order. 4
The defendant claims that the judge abused his discretion in denying the motions, and that the orders, in essence, were orders of impoundment not supported by good cause. At oral argument before this court, the Commonwealth raised for the first time the question whether these orders are interlocutory and therefore not immediately appealable.
5
If so, then we are without subject matter jurisdiction and the appeal must be dismissed. See
Commonwealth
v.
Swist
,
Discussion
. The defendant claims that he needs the juror information in order to contact the seated jurors pursuant to the procedures set forth in
Commonwealth
v.
Moore
,
While there are no cases that explicitly address the nature of the motions before us, we look for guidance to those cases involving a request for postconviction discovery because the defendant's motion seeks information that may be material and relevant to a motion for new trial. See Mass. R. Crim. P. 30(c)(4), as appearing in
*728
*693
Generally speaking "discovery orders are interlocutory."
Cronin
v.
Strayer
,
The same aversion to appellate review of interlocutory orders applies where an interlocutory order concerns a postconviction ruling. See
Scott
v.
Commonwealth
,
Thus, without addressing the viability of the defendant's motion, the defendant is not without a remedy. In the ordinary course, the defendant may pursue his motion in conjunction with a motion for new trial. See
Commonwealth
v.
Murphy
,
We pause to note that a properly filed motion for juror information requires a judge to conduct a two-step analysis. General Laws c. 234A, § 67, requires that a list of all jurors summonsed to jury service be available for inspection by the parties, counsel, their agents, and members of the public. See
Commonwealth
v.
Fujita
,
Appeal dismissed .
After a trial by jury, the defendant was convicted of armed assault with intent to rob a person older than sixty years, assault and battery on an elderly or disabled person causing serious bodily injury, armed robbery, and aggravated assault and battery by means of a dangerous weapon. After a jury-waived trial, the defendant was convicted as a habitual offender on the four indictments.
The judge acting on all posttrial motions was also the trial judge.
The defendant's direct appeal has been vacated without prejudice to reentry after disposition of this appeal and the conclusion of any other posttrial motions.
Because "[s]ubject matter jurisdiction cannot be conferred by consent, conduct or waiver," it may be raised for the first time on appeal.
Litton Business Sys
. v.
Commissioner of Revenue
,
Subsequently, the appeal was dismissed. See note 4.
When requesting postconviction discovery, a defendant by affidavit "must make a sufficient showing that the discovery is reasonably likely to uncover evidence that might warrant granting a new trial."
Daniels
,
By statute, orders denying motions for postconviction access to forensic and scientific analysis, are "final and appealable." See G. L. c. 278A, § 18. These are fundamentally distinct from the nature of the motions before us. General Laws c. 278A was enacted in 2012 as a result of significant changes and advancements in the field of DNA evidence. St. 2012, c. 38. See
Commonwealth
v.
Donald
,
Because the defendant's argument that the order denying the release of juror information is tantamount to an order of impoundment is not properly before us, we need not reach that question.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.