Willington v. Inhabitants of West Boylston
Willington v. Inhabitants of West Boylston
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court. It is no doubt true, that whenever the performance of a contract becomes impossible by an act of God, no action will lie to recover damages for the non-performance.
It is a well-established principle in cases of mutual covenants or promises, that if one thing be the consideration of the other, there a performance is necessary to be averred, unless a day is appointed for the performance, or some other circumstance appears, showing the intention of the parties to rely on their respective covenants or promises.
Admitting this as the sound rule of construction, there can be no doubt as to the true consideration of the defendants’ promise. Here was no time appointed for the payment of the money. The defendants agree to pay a dollar per week for the board, clothing, and nursing of the pauper for the term of a year. And the plaintiff, to entitle himself to compensation according to this contract, must aver and prove performance on his part. The rule laid down by Lord Holt, in the case of Thorpe v. Thorpe, 1 Salk. 171, is in point. u In executory contracts, if the agreement be, that the one shall do an act, and for the doing thereof the other shall pay, &c. the doing of the act is a condition precedent to the payment.” It is very clear, therefore, that if nothing had intervened to excuse the plaintiff from performing his part of the contract,
Where a purchaser of land hag performed in part the terms of the contract, and the failure to perform the residue has been occasioned by circumstances which neither party could control, equity will arrange a just compensation to the purchaser, and charge it upon the land sold. Williams v. Champion, 6 Ohio R. 170.
See Chitty on Contracts, (3d Amer. ed.) 273; 10 Amer. Jurist, 250 to 253; Platt on Covenants, 275, (Law Libr. JVo. 7, p. 275.)
See Platt on Covenants, 83 et seq., 105,106, (Law Libr. JVo. 7, p. 83 <1 seq., 105,106.) 1 Chitty on PI. (6th Amer. ed.) 355, 356.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ebenezer Willington versus The Inhabitants of West Boylston
- Status
- Published