Ingraham v. Doggett
Ingraham v. Doggett
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court. The question for our consideration is, whether- assessors are liable in trespass for an irregularity or unintentional error, in the discharge of their official duties.
By St. 1823, c. 138, § 5, it is enacted, that assessors shall not be responsible for the assessment of any tax upon the inhabitants of any city, town, district, parish or religious society of which they are assessors, when thereto required by the constituted authorities thereof, but the liability, if any, shall rest solely with said city, &c., and the assessors shall be responsible only for their own fidelity and integrity.
This statute was obviously made for the purpose of lightening the burdens of an office, to which belong important and difficult duties, and which the citizen, when elected thereto, may not accept or decline at his option. Does its protection extend to the accidental mistakes of assessors, or are they still liable, in trespass, for every legal error, however innocently made ?
It is contended by the plaintiff’s counsel, that the provision only relieves assessors from their liability for assessing a sum of money unlawfully raised ; as where a town proceeds ille gaily in making a grant, or makes one which by law it has no
Assessors, while executing the duties required of them, are exempted from all responsibility except for their own integrity and fidelity. That accidental mistakes in the performance of duties, the details of which are complicated" and difficult, are consistent with pure integrity and strict fidelity, cannot be doubted. And we are clearly of opinion, that assessors, in making assessments which they are required by their towns, districts, parishes or religious societies to make, are liable only for fraudulent and corrupt conduct; and that for their unintentional errors and mistakes, their towns, parishes, &c., only are responsible.
Motion to take off nonsuit overruled.
See Revised Stat. c. 7, § 44; Gage v. Currier, 4 Pick. 399; Mosher v Robie, 2 Fairfield, 135; Withington v. Eveleth, 7 Pick. 106; Inglee v. Bosworth, post, 498.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Elijah Ingraham versus Robert Doggett
- Status
- Published