Thomas v. Le Baron
Thomas v. Le Baron
Opinion of the Court
Upon the facts reported, we are of opinion that the demandant is entitled to recover one undivided ninth part of the demanded premises, as one of the heirs at law of Elijah Thomas, excepting five acres, to which, it is admitted, the tenant has a good title. The demandant’s claim to the whole was disposed of at the trial, and is waived. The question now is, whether the title of Elijah Thomas was valid, and paramount to that of the tenant. The objection is, that the deed to him from Seth Southworth, the administrator of Sylvanus Tillson, was void ; he not being licensed to make sale of the said estate, as required by St. 1788, c. 51, <§> 3, which was then in force. • But we are of opinion that the tenant cannot avail himself of this objection. We consider this conveyance as valid, except as against the heirs of Tillson. The administrator was seized of the estate conveyed, in trust for the widow and heirs of Tillson; and it would be of no importance to any other person whether the estate were sold, or held in trust for them. The administrator has accounted for the proceeds of the sale, in the probate court, and no objection has been made by the heirs of Tillson. The tenant could not be prejudiced by the sale, for it did not deprive him of his right of redemption. And to him it must be immaterial whether the title passed by the administrator’s deed to Elijah Thomas, or still remains the property of the administrator ; for if the deed were void, the tenant would be liable to be ejected by the administrator. Considering these circumstances, we are of opinion that the deed of the administraior is not void, and could have been avoided only by the heirs; and they have elected, as they had a right to do, not to avoid, but to confirm it, by acquiescing in the settlement of the account of administration in the probate court, in which they were credited for the purchase money. And this we consider as equivalent to a deed of confirmation from
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Lucy Thomas v. John Le Baron
- Status
- Published