Commonwealth v. Harvey
Commonwealth v. Harvey
Opinion of the Court
There is no doubt that John Shea was properly permitted to testify to what was said to him by the teamster in presence of the defendant. It was a material inquiry upon the trial of the indictment against him, whether he was, at the time specified in it, in possession of a considerable quantity of spirituous liquors, put up in such casks and vessels as it is usually kept in when prepared and intended for sale. And the evidence offered tended to show that he was. For an admission of a party may sometimes be implied from his acquiescence in what is asserted by others in his hearing, as well as proved by evidence of his own direct and distinct declaration. But the instructions, according to the brief and perhaps imperfect report of them in the bill of exceptions, under which the testimony of Shea was submitted to the jury, did not explain the principle upon which it was admissible, and were consequently calculated to give it a force and effect to which, without proof of other facts, it was not legally entitled. In connection with the information given them, that the remark of the teamster was competent evidence, if it was heard by the defendant, no advice or caution was given them to consider the circumstances under which it was made. They were told only not to regard it, unless they were satisfied it was heard. This implied, or at any rate might seem to the jmy to imply, that if he did hear it, his silence was, at all events, and without any reference to the accompanying
As the explanations, necessary to enable the jury rightly to understand and appreciate the rule of law, under which they were to deliberate and decide upon the evidence before them, did not accompany the instructions which were given them by the presiding judge, and as they might, in consequence of such deficiency, have allowed it too much weight and importance, a new trial must be granted. Exceptions sustained.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.