Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1854

Commonwealth v. Hilliard

Commonwealth v. Hilliard
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided October 15, 1854
68 Mass. 294

Commonwealth v. Hilliard

Opinion of the Court

By the Court.

The evidence is inadmissible. If such evidence were admitted on behalf of the prisoner, it would be competent for the Commonwealth to show that the deceased was of a mild and peaceable character. Such evidence is too remote and uncertain to have any legitimate bearing on the question at issue. The provocation under which the defendant acted must be judged of by the res gestee; and the evidence must be confined to the facts and circumstances attending the assault by the deceased upon the defendant.

Verdict, guilty of mcmslmghter.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.