Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1855

Inhabitants of Northampton v. Elwell

Inhabitants of Northampton v. Elwell
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided September 15, 1855 · Shaw
70 Mass. 81

Inhabitants of Northampton v. Elwell

Opinion of the Court

Shaw, C. J.*

The court are all of opinion that an action on this bond cannot be maintained in the name of the inhabitants of Northampton. The whole legal title to maintain the action consists in the deed by which the defendant has bound himself to the Commonwealth. The right of action on a sealed instrument belongs to the party having the legal interest. This is now well settled. Sanders v. Filley, 12 Pick. 554. Johnson v. Foster, 12 Met. 167. Millard v. Baldwin, 3 Gray, 484.

Many other points taken by the defendant, and very well argued by counsel, would deserve great care and attention, were not the one stated quite decisive.

Demurrer sustained.

Dewey, J. did not sit in tins case.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.