Case v. Pettee
Case v. Pettee
Opinion of the Court
A majority of the court are of opinion that this action cannot be maintained.
1. The bond not being given in any penal sum, but only “ in the full and just sum of double the value of the property to be replevied, to be ascertained by three disinterested and discreet
2. But if this bond were valid in other respects, this action could not be maintained; because the case shows that no sum was ever fixed by appraisers. It appears by the officer’s return that the parties agreed on the value, and no appraisers were ever appointed according to the statute. If the maxim, that that is certain which can be made certain, could apply, it would not avail here; because the amount never was made certain by appraisers in the manner pointed out in the penal part of the bond. It is like a penal bond with the sum left, blank.
Exceptions sustained.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Alfred Case v. Benjamin Pettee & another
- Status
- Published