McIntyre v. Park
Opinion of the Court
We express no opinion on the question whether the sum of five hundred dollars, mentioned in the agreement upon which this action is brought, is a penalty or liquidated damages. That point was ruled in the defendant’s favor, and the plaintiff has not excepted to the ruling.
We cannot see that the jury ought to have been instructed to find only nominal damages. It does not appear that all the evidence as to damages is set forth in the bill of exceptions. The instructions on that subject seem to us to have been right; and if the jury assessed larger damages than the evidence legally warranted, the defendant should have moved for a new trial on that ground. We must suppose, in this stage of the case, either that there was evidence of damages, which is not reported, or that the jury judged, from the nature of the case, what was the amount of the damages which the plaintiff had sustained — as they always do in those actions in which general damages only are claimed in the plaintiff’s declaration, and in which the law has prescribed no fixed rule of damages.
All the other rulings and instructions, to which exceptions have been alleged, we think were correct; and we deem it unnecessary to do more than simply to affirm them.
Exceptions overruled.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.