Cushman v. Libbey
Cushman v. Libbey
Opinion of the Court
The various exceptions taken by the plaintiff in the course of the trial become immaterial, if the final ruling upon which he submitted to a verdict was correct.
It was decided in Wall v. Lakin, 13 Met. 167, that the provisions of the St. 1841, c. 124, § 3, did not apply to the case of the payment of a debt in money; and that such a payment could not be set aside by the assignees of an insolvent debtor, nor the money paid be recovered back for distribution among his creditors, although the payment was made under circumstances which would have made “ any assignment, sale, transfer or conveyance, either absolute or conditional, of any part of his estate” void and invalid as against the assignees. As this case
It is true that a check drawn upon a deposit in a bank is not in itself money. It is an order for the payment of money, and somewhat resembles a bill of exchange. But so bank bills are not money. They are promissory notes, payable to the bearer; a peculiar kind of promissory notes, intended for circulation as money, usually treated as money, and discharging many of the offices of money, but deriving all their title to be called or regarded as money merely .from the consent of those who use them. Among merchants it is almost as common to pay obligations by means of bank checks, especially in large transactions, as by means of bank notes. In our cities, a very common, if not the most common, mode of payment is for the debtor to draw a check, which the creditor receives and deposits in the bank where he keeps his account; and the bank receives the deposit as if it were money, and collects it of the bank upon which the check is drawn, as it would the bills of that bank if they had been deposited instead. By commercial usage, a check thus drawn in payment of a pecuniary obligation is not regarded as a negotiable instrument assigned to the party who takes it, depending upon the general credit or solvency of the drawer; but as importing that the money is on deposit in the bank, ready to be paid on the presentment of the check, so that it is substantially equivalent to the present possession of the money itself, while it may be more convenient to both parties than the actual manual delivery of bank bills or cash. So in some parts of the country ingots of gold, bearing the stamp of the government assay, or, for small transactions, post-office stamps and treasury notes, are treated and used as a currency.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Julius Cushman v. Washington Libbey
- Status
- Published