Damon v. Damon
Damon v. Damon
Opinion of the Court
There seems to be no reason upon principle why an instrument cannot be made which is to take effect as a will only on the happening of a contingency named in it. As every devise or legacy, and the appointment of an executor, may be made conditional, if the same condition applies to all, it may be as well annexed to the entire instrument as to a single provision ; and the happening of the condition can then be ascertained when the will is offered for probate. And so it has been held in various cases which have been cited at the bar.
But there are two points to be settled before a will can be rejected from probate on the ground that it is a conditional will, and that the condition has failed; first, whether the intention of the testator is to make the validity of the will dependent upon the condition, or merely to state the circumstances and inducements which lead him to make a testamentary provision; and secondly, if the language clearly imports a condition, whether it applies to and affects the whole will, or only some parts of it.
We are unable to see that, on any sound principle of construction, the language used in this will can be taken to express merely the cause and inducement of making it. The introductory clause is complete in itself, in a form quite common", and states distinctly the motive of the testator in making the will. “ I, J. W. Damon, of......being in sound mind and body, and being about to go to Cuba, and knowing the dangers of voyages, do hereby make this as my last will and testament, in manner and form following.” So far, what is said applies to the whole instrument. Then come the particular dispositions : “ First, If by casualty or otherwise I should lose my life during this voyage, I give and bequeath to my wife Ann,” &c. The
The other reasons urged for the opinion that the whole will was made “lest the testator should die during the voyage,” namely, the appointment of his wife as accountant to settle his affairs in Cuba “ and all other places where I may have business at the time of my decease,” he having no business elsewhere than in Cuba and Charlestown when the will was made, and the repetition of the phrase “ this my last will and testament,” whatever weight might be given to them if the sole question were whether the whole will must fail if he accomplished the voyage in safety, are deprived of all force if the condition affects but a single clause.
And upon the second question proposed, we are of opinion that the condition does not affect any other than the first clause of the will, and that the will is therefore entitled to probate, having been duly executed.
The case most nearly analogous, to be found among the adjudged cases, is that of Parsons v. Lanoe, cited from 1 Ves. Sen, 189, but also to be found in Ambl. 557. Each of these reports is apparently imperfect and fragmentary ; but, by taking both, a pretty correct idea of the case can be obtained. The report in Ambler is the best, so far as it gives the will itself more at length; and some of the expressions attributed to Lord Hardwicke in Vesey, to which it is hard to give a sensible meaning, are not found in it. As there recited, the will began thus-
In the case at bar, the condition stands very much as in
The cases cited at the argument, with the exception of Parsons v. Lanoe, afford but little aid in coming to the decision at which we have arrived, and are chiefly valuable as showing that courts do not incline to regard a will as conditional where it can be reasonably held that the testator was merely expressing his inducement to make it, however inaccurate his use of language might be, if strictly construed. But no authority has been found which would justify us in rejecting this will as wholly conditional.
We intend to express no opinion upon the point, how far the condition qualifies the devises in the first clause. It is very difficult to give all of the provisions a sensible interpretation, and one of the parties largely interested has not been a party to the hearing. We only decide that the will is to be admitted to probate. Decree affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Teresa Damon & another v. Ann Damon
- Cited By
- 3 cases
- Status
- Published