First Methodist Episcopal Society v. Brayton
First Methodist Episcopal Society v. Brayton
Opinion of the Court
The right of the plaintiffs to assess a tax for which the defendant, as owner of a pew in the meeting-house used and occupied by the corporation, can be held personally liable, exists, if at all, by virtue of a clause in the deed under which the defendant acquired a title to his pew. By the terms of this clause, the right to assess such tax is strictly defined and limited, and cannot be exercised for any purpose not therein specifically named. If in making an assessment a tax is laid for a purpose not included within "the authority reserved to the corporation, then it is clear that the defendant is not chargeable therefor, because no promise .can be implied by his acceptance of a deed poll beyond the letter of the deed on which the promise is raised. By the facts proved at the trial, it is apparent that in making the assessment of which the tax in question forms an aliquot part, several items of expenditure were embraced which do not come within the scope of the authority reserved to the society, and which they were not empowered to include as
Exceptions overruled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- First Methodist Episcopal Society v. John Brayton
- Status
- Published