Pratt v. Farrar
Pratt v. Farrar
Opinion of the Court
By the law of Massachusetts, as by the English common law, a tenancy at will may be terminated by alienation of the land either by landlord or tenant; and a written lease for years from the landlord to a third person has the same effect as a conveyance in fee. Benedict v. Morse, 10 Met. 229. Kelly v. Waite, 12 Met. 302, 303. Howard v. Merriam, 5 Cush. 574, 580. Curtis v. Galvin, 1 Allen, 216. Cooper v. Adams, 6 Cush. 90, 91. This form of expressing the will to end the tenancy, taking place off the land and in ths absence of the other party, must be made known to him, in order to give effect to the intention and actually terminate the tenancy, although no particular form of notice is required. Furlong v. Leary, 8 Cush. 410 Mizner v.
It may indeed be doubted whether the ruling was not too favorable, and whether, upon the defendant’s estate at will being terminated by his knowledge of an alienation inconsistent with its continuance, the rightful owner might not at once maintain an action to recover the land. McFarland v. Chase, 7 Gray, 463. Howard v. Merriam, 5 Cush. 578. Doe v. M’Kaeg, 10 B. & C. 723, 724; S. C. 6 Man. & Ry. 621, 622. Doe v. Turner, 7 M. & W. 235.
But it is unnecessary to express a decisive opinion upon that; for we concur in the opinion of the judge who presided at the trial, that the defendant was allowed a reasonable time to remove himself and his family, under the circumstances of the- case. The facts not being in dispute, what was reasonable time was rightly treated as a question of law. Co. Litt. 56 b. Ellis v. Paige, 1 Pick. 50; S. C. 2 Pick. 71, note. The written- lease was made on the 29th of March, to take effect from- the 31st, and was not suspended by the stipulation not to claim rent until the lessee should be in actual possession. The tenement was the lower story of a house in the city of Springfield. It does not appear that the defendant’s wife’s health was so feeble that she could not assist in removing, or that his child was too sick to be removed and it does appear that their state of health was
Exceptions overruled.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Mary A. Pratt v. Benjamin F. Farrar
- Status
- Published