Chapman v. Kellogg
Cases that cite this one
13 later published cases cite this decision.
- MacKeown v. Lacey (Mass. 1909)
- Blackwell v. Blackwell (Mass. 1907)
- National Bank of the Republic v. Delano (Mass. 1904)
- Spencer v. Stockwell (Vt. 1904)
- Rogers v. Wolfe (Mo. 1890)
- Martin v. Martin (Mass. 1888)
- Butler v. Ives (Mass. 1885)
- Fowle v. Torrey (Mass. 1883)
- Franklin Savings Bank v. Greene (R.I. 1882)
- Degnan v. Farr (Mass. 1879)
- Roby v. Phelon (Mass. 1875)
- Bassett v. Bassett (Mass. 1873)
- Abbott v. Winchester (Mass. 1870)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The note in' suit was originally valid, having been given to the plaintiff by the defendant while she was sole. When she married Kellogg, it remained valid against her; but under our present statute her husband did not become liable to pay it. Gen. Sts.' c. 108, § 8.
According to the plaintiff’s testimony, he sold it to her husband, and indorsed it to him, and thus the husband acquired the legal as well as the equitable title to it. The agreement, that the plaintiff should take it back in case of any difficulty between the defendant and her husband, did not prevent the title from vesting absolutely in the husband, for the husband was under no obligation to return it, except at his own option.
This note then, when it passed into the hands of the defendant’s husband, he having the legal as well as equitable title to it, became a nullity. And, it having been once extinguished, he had no power to revive it against her by retransferring it to the plaintiff. The question here decided is different from that decided in Bemis v. Call, 10 Allen, 512.
Exceptions sustained.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.