Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1873

Commonwealth v. Harvey

Commonwealth v. Harvey
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided January 15, 1873 · Gkay
111 Mass. 420

Counsel

C. F. Donnelly, for the defendant., J". Q. Davis, Assistant Attorney General, for the Commonwealth.

Commonwealth v. Harvey

Opinion of the Court

Gkay, J.

All the points made in this case are covered by previous decisions. The objections to the complaint were formal, and not having been made in the Municipal Court, to which the complaint was originally presented, were not open in the Superior Court. Commonwealth v. Walton, 11 Allen, 238. Commonwealth v. Vincent, 108 Mass. 441. The objections to the service of the Warrant could not be made for the first time in the Superior Court. Commonwealth v. Henry, 7 Cush. 512. Commonwealth v. Gregory, 7 Gray, 498. The attestation of the record by the assistant clerk of the Municipal Court was sufficient. Commonwealth v. Clark, 16 Gray, 88. Commonwealth v. Connell, 9 Allen, 488. Any irregularity in the proceedings of the Municipal Court presented no ground for dismissing the complaint in the court appealed to ; for the appeal vacated the judgment below and gave the defendant his full rights in the court above. Commonwealth v. O'Neil, 6 Gray, 343. Commonwealth v. Tinkham, 14 Gray, 12. Commonwealth v. McCormack, 7 Allen, 532.

Exceptions overruled.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.