Byrom v. Chapin
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- James v. City of Worcester (Mass. 1886)
- Morris Plan Co. v. Hillcrest Farms Dairy, Inc. (Mass. 1948)
- W. & R. Investment Co. v. Edwards Supply Co. (Mass. 1939)
- Federal Land Bank of Columbia v. Jones (N.C. 1937)
- Delano v. Smith (Mass. 1910)
- Belmont Mining & Milling Co. v. Costigan (Colo. 1895)
- Verner v. Betz (N.J. 1889)
- Allen v. Butman (Mass. 1885)
- Schalk v. Kingsley (N.J. 1880)
- Morgan v. Gilbert (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Michigan 1880)
- Searle v. Sawyer (Mass. 1879)
- Wilson v. European & North American Railway Co. (Me. 1877)
- Jackson v. Turrell (N.J. 1877)
- King v. Bangs (Mass. 1876)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This case must be governed by the decision in Gooding v. Shea, 103 Mass. 360. The owner of the equity has no more right than a stranger to impair the security of the mortgagee by removal of buildings or fixtures, thereby causing substantial and permanent injury and depreciation to the mortgaged estate. The right of action in such case is based upon the plaintiff’s interest in the property ; and the damages are measured by the extent of injury to that property. Woodruff v. Halsey, 8 Pick. 333. Page v. Robinson, 10 Cush. 99. It does not depend upon, and the damages are not to be measured by, proof of insufficiency of the remaining security. The mortgagee is not obliged to accept what remains, as satisfaction pro tanto of his debt, at any valuation whatever. He is entitled to the full benefit of the entire mortgaged estate for the full payment of his entire debt.
When such injury has been done, reasonable satisfaction fairly made in good faith to the first mortgagee will discharge the claim as to all other interests.
The ruling excluding this evidence, as well as the ruling that the action could not be maintained, were erroneous, and there must accordingly be a New trial.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.