Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1879

Commonwealth v. Fraher

Commonwealth v. Fraher
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided January 30, 1879 · Gray
126 Mass. 265; 1879 Mass. LEXIS 230

Commonwealth v. Fraher

Opinion of the Court

Gray, C. J.

At the time of the trial of this complaint, no judgment had been rendered upon the verdict of guilty on the former indictment, and the question whether that verdict should stand was still open and pending on a bill of exceptions filed by the defendant himself. Under these circumstances, even assuming both prosecutions to be for the same offence, the former verdict will not support the plea of autrefois convict. Commonwealth v. Lahy, 8 Gray, 459, 461. What might be the effect of that verdict, if the defendant had never taken or had afterwards waived his exceptions, and stood ready to abide his sentence thereon, this case does not require us to consider. See Commonwealth v. Roby, 12 Pick. 496, 510; Commonwealth v. Harris, 8 Gray, 470, 473; State v. Elden, 41 Maine, 165; Stark. Crim. Pl. (2d ed.) 330. Exceptions overruled.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.