Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1891

Hoey v. Inhabitants of Natick

Hoey v. Inhabitants of Natick
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided May 19, 1891 · Allen
153 Mass. 528; 27 N.E. 595; 1891 Mass. LEXIS 328

Hoey v. Inhabitants of Natick

Opinion of the Court

C. Allen, J.

The two rulings asked for were properly refused.

1. It was impossible to lay down as a rule of law that the town would have notice of a defect in the structure, if the cesspool was in fact defectively built, and was put in by others than by the town itself. That was a question of fact.

2. The fact of the existence of a private cesspool within the limits of a public way is not decisive of negligence on the part of the town. Many uses may properly be made of land within the limits of a public way, and beneath the surface thereof, which are not inconsistent with the public easement.

^Exceptions overruled.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.