Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1891

Commonwealth v. Goodnow

Commonwealth v. Goodnow
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided October 24, 1891 · Holmes
154 Mass. 487; 28 N.E. 677; 1891 Mass. LEXIS 164

Commonwealth v. Goodnow

Opinion of the Court

Holmes, J.

1. The admission of the first question did the defendant no harm, as his counsel had admitted the fact in his opening, and as the defendant’s answer, so far as responsive, denied it.

2. Carr’s denial that he had drunk intoxicating liquor for the past two years went to support his denial that he was drunk at the time in question, and indeed would seem to have been the form in which the latter denial was put. Therefore it was subject to contradiction. See Riddell v. Thayer, 127 Mass. 487, 489.

Hxceptions overruled.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.