Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1895

Commonwealth v. Porter

Commonwealth v. Porter
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided November 27, 1895 · Holmes
164 Mass. 576; 42 N.E. 97; 1895 Mass. LEXIS 296

Commonwealth v. Porter

Opinion of the Court

Holmes, J.

The word “ cruelly,” in Pub. Sts. c. 207, § 53, exhausts the requirements of the statute, whatever they may be, with regard to the state of mind of the actor; (Commonwealth v. McClellan, 101 Mass. 34, 35 ; Commonwealth v. Lufkin, 7 Allen, 579;) and therefore an allegation that the defendant “did then and there cruelly drive ” the horse, following the statute, is sufficient without a further allegation that the defendant knew the horse to be unfit for labor at the time. See Commonwealth v. Barrett, 108 Mass. 302. Exceptions overruled.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.