Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, 1925

Blakely's Case

Blakely's Case
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Decided April 18, 1925 · Carroll
252 Mass. 212; 147 N.E. 576; 1925 Mass. LEXIS 1359

Blakely's Case

Opinion of the Court

Carroll, J.

The employee was fatally injured as a result of a fall on the ice on a public highway. The injury did not arise out of his employment. It was not caused by it. The injury came from a hazard common to all who had occasion to use the public highway. It is impossible to distinguish this case from Donahue’s Case, 226 Mass. 595, where it was held that an employee could not recover for an injury caused by a fall on an icy street. The case is governed by Donahue’s Case. See Whitley’s Case, ante, 211, and cases cited.

The decree must be reversed and a decree entered for the insurer.

So ordered.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.