Margosian v. Markarian
Cases that cite this one
24 later published cases cite this decision.
- Slusher v. State (Ind. Ct. App. 1982)
- King v. G & M REALTY CORP. (Mass. 1977)
- Spodek v. United States Postal Service (District Court, D. Massachusetts 1999)
- Hodge v. Klug (Mass. App. Ct. 1992)
- In re 29 Newbury Street, Inc., Debtor. Saunders & Associates v. 29 Newbury Street, Inc. (1st Cir. 1988)
- In re 29 Newbury Street, Inc. (United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts 1987)
- In re Players' Pub, Inc. (United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts 1985)
- Matter of Norwood Aviation, Inc. (United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts 1985)
- King v. G & M Realty Corp. (Mass. Dist. Ct., App. Div. 1970)
- Galjaard v. Day (Mass. 1950)
- Hampton v. Mott Motors, Inc. (D.C. 1943)
- Souza v. Becker (Mass. 1938)
- Retained Realty, Inc. v. Green Tech Corp. (District Court, D. Massachusetts 2023)
- Federal National Mortgage Association v. Gordon (Mass. App. Ct. 2017)
- Homer Apartments, LP v. Postoronka (Mass. Dist. Ct., App. Div. 2013)
- Poutahidis v. Clingan (Mass. Dist. Ct., App. Div. 2001)
- C. Healy Associates, Inc. v. Concord Oil Co. (Mass. Dist. Ct., App. Div. 1992)
- Brown v. Guerrier (Mass. 1983)
- Farris v. Hershfield (Mass. 1950)
- Brogna v. Kaplovitz (Massachusetts District Court 1949)
- Carter v. Yardley & Co. (Mass. 1946)
- Carney v. Conveyancers Title Insurance & Mortgage Co. (Mass. 1941)
- Mescall v. Somerset Savings Bank (Mass. 1940)
- Adjmi v. Ginter Restaurant Co. (Mass. 1935)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This is an action of tort to recover for personal injuries received by the plaintiff on April 18, 1933, as the result of a fall on a defective stairway upon premises occupied by the plaintiff and her husband and owned by the defendant.
The trial judge found that “Upon all the evidence . . . the plaintiff was injured by reason of a defect in a stairway in a house owned and controlled by the defendant and that said injuries happened on April 18, 1933. . . . that the notice to vacate for nonpayment of rent was duly received by the plaintiff’s husband on April 1, 1933. . . . [and] that on April 14, 1933, the defendant commenced action for possession of the premises occupied by the plaintiff and the plaintiff’s husband.” He ruled “that the plaintiff’s husband at the time of the accident was a tenant at sufferance in the premises. . . . [and] that the plaintiff is in no better position in regard to the premises than her husband.” He further found “that there was no wanton or wilful act committed by the defendant which caused- the injuries to the plaintiff, and that the husband of the plaintiff and the plaintiff herself both stand in the position as tenants at sufferance,” and he therefore found for the defendant. The plaintiff in her brief states that she'“is the widow of a former tenant at will of the defendant.” The trial judge found, and the plaintiff’s counsel admitted, that the plaintiff’s husband was in arrears for rent, that he had received a notice to quit for nonpayment of rent more, than fourteen days prior to the accident, and that her husband had been served with summary process to vacate the premises
The only question presented for decision is whether the trial judge erred in ruling that the plaintiff’s husband at the time of the accident was a tenant at sufferance, that the plaintiff was in no better- position than her husband, and Accordingly in the absence of wanton or wilful act on the part of the defendant the plaintiff was not entitled to recover.
A tenant at sufferance has no estate nor title, but only a naked possession, without right and wrongfully, and stands in no privity to the landlord. Benton v. Williams, 202 Mass. 189, 192. A tenant at sufferance is not entitled to notice to quit but is a holder without right. Kelly v. Waite, 12 Met. 300, 302. A tenant at sufferance is a bare licensee to whom the landlord owes merely the duty not wantonly nor wilfully to injure him. Bruso v. Eastern States Exposition, 269 Mass. 21, 24, 25. Coulombe v. Horne Coal Co. 275 Mass. 226, 230. Brennan v. Keene, 237 Mass. 556, 561. There was no evidence which would warrant a finding that the plaintiff’s injuries were due to any wanton or wilful act committed by the defendant. In addition to the common law rule that a tenancy at sufferance comes into existence when the landlord gives notice to quit for nonpayment of rent, the same result follows under G. L. (Ter. Ed.) c. 186, § 12, which provides in part as follows: “. . . in case of neglect or refusal to pay the rent due from a tenant at will, fourteen days’ notice to quit, given in writing by the landlord to the tenant, shall be sufficient to determine the tenancy.”
Counsel for the plaintiff has cited Osborne v. Wells, 213 Mo. App. 319. In that case the court denied a request for a ruling in substance to the effect that where a notice to quit for nonpayment of rent had been given the landlord
As there was no error in the "rulings given and in the judge’s refusals to rule, or in the decision of the Appellate Division, the entry must be
Order dismissing report affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.